Let a Thousand Filters Bloom
Testo originale ed alterazioni
Lucio Spaziante, Thursday, February 28, 2002 7:17 PM (Paris time)
First, the internet is replete with filters, though not necessarily the authoritative filters Eco would like. Most associations, such as, say, the International Society for Philosophy, provide lists of recommended works. Additionally, many authorities in different fields publish newsletters or weblogs identifying and recommending useful works. The person who relies only on Google may be lost, but nobody relies only on Google.
Second, there is much less of a need for filters than Eco supposes. In a literate society, the vast majority of people are able to distinguish between quality work and that of the less-qualified fringe. People are moreover able to critically assess even the authorities and draw their own conclusions. Filters are perhaps necessary for a pre-literate culture, but we have progressed well beyond those medieval days.
I respect Eco’s assertion that the filters he has in mind do not function in the manner of the censor. And no doubt it is not the intent of the publisher who selects manuscripts or the editor who referees an article to prohibit a certain body of opinion from being distributed. But where a filter is placed between the reader and the body of content, then no matter how benign the original intent, the effect is the same as censorship. It is not possible to prevent one’s opinions on quality culture, scholarship and criticism from screening out certain points of view, certain means of expression. Free access to information requires disintermediated access to information. That there are certain risks is self evident, as is the case with any form of self government. That, however, the benefits far outweigh the risks is also self evident. For in the question of knowledge as well as in any question of authority, the age old question arises: who censors the censors?
Stephen Downes, Thursday, February 28, 2002 3:08 PM (Paris time)
competing encyclopaedia and filters
The skills of filtering certainly need to be fostered. We are beginning to see this where emphasis is placed on problem-based learning rather than exams.
In fact children are surprisingly critical, already, assessing the validitiy and authority of reviews of games etc. Whether they are encouraged to apply this thinking elsewhere I am not sure.
An alternative, as noted, is the professional filter, where info. is evaluated by ‘experts’, ‘peers’. In the medical field we now see the use of the evidence-based approach to information, where research and articles are rated (one star, two star …) according to scientific rigour. Perhaps this approach will be more widely applied.
As to the demise of writing, it has been shown that many children (often those that have writing difficulties) write more when using the computer – it’s neat and has spell checks.
I agree that the paper domain still has many advantages for the reader. The retrieval, presentation and use of information electronically is probably at a similar point to the development of cars in the 1920s. Crank the handle, make sure you’re wearing goggles … more for the persistent adventurers.
Mark Hepworth, Friday, March 01, 2002 10:56 AM (Paris time)
information filtering?
The problem with information filtering in Internet, is and will always be that the documents in internet couldn’t be retrieved or filtered in an easy way, because all this information lacks the minimal descriptions to recover them. That’s the real problem: there’s no standarized classification method in internet. I think that in a future the Dublin Core metadata project could be the leader in this, but not now.
Sorry if I have some problems with my English, that’s because I usually speak in Spanish. Thanks.
Wilmer Moyano, Sunday, March 10, 2002 8:32 PM (Paris time)
Google est-il un filtre comme les autres ?
Peut-on imaginer un autre système qui ferait apparaître en tête de liste les sites les plus fréquemment visités par les internautes ayant déjà fait la même requête ?
Jocelyn Pierre, Tuesday, March 12, 2002 9:46 AM (Paris time)
Downes-Filters
Yvette Saenz, Tuesday, March 12, 2002 8:21 PM (Paris time)