02 THE CARD INDEX AS CREATIVITY MACHINE

CULTURE MACHINE VOL 11 • 2010
www.culturemachine.net • 7
THE CARD INDEX AS CREATIVITY MACHINE
Rowan Wilken
…everything that matters is to be found in the card box of the researcher who wrote it…
(Benjamin, 1996: 456)
Introduction: Tableau Vivant
A particular photograph of Roland Barthes has always fascinated me. It is a well-known image, taken by Henri Cartier-Bresson in 1963, around the time of the publication of Barthes’ Sur Racine (On Racine). The image is of a youthful Barthes in an office setting, reclining in a chair. He has mute but playful eyes and a sardonic half-smile. His legs are crossed, right over left. He wears crisply creased slacks, and a white shirt under a woollen cardigan. His right arm is hooked over the back of his chair – a rather awkward gesture but one that nevertheless conveys confidence, perhaps even arrogance. His left elbow rests on the left arm of his chair; the left hand is raised and cocked slightly, a cigarette stub between his first two fingers and his thumb. In the background is office shelving, housing various hanging files, and, above these, a series of smaller wooden boxes.
In one sense, this photograph is amusing as a playful homage to a writer Barthes admired and studied in great depth: Michelet. As Barthes’ biographer Louis-Jean Calvet notes, in the course of his research, Barthes ‘had been fascinated by Couture’s portrait of Michelet sitting at his desk with a slightly disdainful, superior air’ (Calvet, 1994: 114-115). Is this a case of Barthes and Cartier-Bresson knowingly recreating this earlier image? The photograph is also revealing if one follows Cartier-Bresson’s own modus operandi and recognises it as a ‘decisive moment’. Interpreting the image in this way, and by reading it, scanning it, as Barthes himself might have done, for a punctum, we might reasonably be drawn to the ever-so-slightly effeminate gesture of the cocked hand and delicately held
WILKEN • THE CARD INDEX CM 11 • 2010
www.culturemachine.net • 8
cigarette. Alternatively, we might fix our gaze on the half-smile and straight-ahead gaze, which seem to speak a certain bemusement or curiosity on the part of the (famous) subject as he poses for the (equally famous) photographer. There exists a kind of ocular repartee between the unsighted photographer and his subject.

Leave a comment