05 Seeing Jane Austen

June 13, 2012

Seeing Jane Austen

Posted by

JaneAustenPortrait_Original_opt.jpg

Last week, researchers unveiled new evidence suggesting that a long-disputed portrait does, in fact, depict a thirteen-year-old Jane Austen. The painting in question is a picture of a very pretty girl with dark eyes and pursed lips, wearing a cloudy-white Empire-waist dress. Since the late nineteenth century, members of a branch of Austen’s family have contended that it is a portrait of their famous ancestor—but historians have disputed the claim, saying that the style of the girl’s dress was not in fashion until Austen was twenty years old.

The new evidence comes from early photos of the portrait (taken in 1910, before the painting underwent several restorations) that reveal Austen’s name, the name of the painter, and the date 1789, at which time Austen was thirteen. If the girl in the painting really is Jane Austen then the portrait is the only professionally painted likeness of her—and it joins a sketch by Austen’s sister and, possibly, an unauthenticated drawing discovered last year by the Austen biographer Paula Byrne, among the only known portraits of the author created during her lifetime. These unearthed pictures, historical debates, and “Blow-Up”-style investigations reinforce the celebrity aura that has developed around Austen in recent years.

It’s difficult to think of another writer whose life story holds such popular fascination or whose works define such a commonly lusted-after fantasy world. The expansion of the Austen universe, pushing it into familiar genres and conventions (the alternate-ending novels, the choose-your-own-adventure books, and of course the zombies) is omnipresent. And who by now couldn’t describe Georgian-era formal wear fairly accurately thanks to the multiple film adaptations of almost all of Austen’s books? For such an un-cinematic author, her posthumous career has taken a cinematic, image-driven turn.

Austen’s life took place in a sphere of drawing rooms and country walks, where psychological and social drama simmered under a thick layer of protocol. While Mary Shelley created trans-European scandal with Percy, and Anne Radcliffe “caverned” and “waterfalled” her readers with wild Gothic tales, Austen never married, never travelled far, and wrote books in which high drama was a loaded conversation or a twisted ankle. Yet it is Austen who inspires the A-list Hollywood biopics.

The hubhub around a possible discovery of an unknown Austen portrait is a symptom of the same impulse that drives us to translate her works into more accessible versions. It is a true that we live in a visual culture, but it is also true that we live in a culture in which self-presentation and social nuance are topics of keen interest. Confronted with an author like Austen, who offers piercing comprehension of our social habits but doesn’t provide much by way of compelling visuals, we’ve created a visual world in which to house her so that we can enjoy the candles, teas, and bonnets while we consider her weighty human insights.

When Paula Byrne announced her discovery of an alleged Austen portrait last year, she said it “has the potential to change our image of her for ever” because it shows “a professional writer at the height of her powers” rather than the “prim spinster” seen in the familiar sketch by Austen’s sister, Cassandra. The Guardian noted that the new portrait presented a contrast to Cassandra’s drawing, in which Austen “looks cross.”

We shouldn’t need a picture to prove that Austen was not always grouchy, or that she took her writing seriously. Nor do we need a picture to prove that she was once thirteen years old. But our reading of Austen has been visually augmented, so that we are used to reading her texts along with Colin Firth’s barely raised eyebrows and Gwyneth Paltrow’s furrowed brow. Of all writers, she is one that we would like to visualize accurately, in the half-belief that if we could just get a good look at her, we would be able to see something more of her world.

Keywords

1 comment | Add your comments

An alternative view of the recent Rice family claim is to be found on the Web site of the art historian Bendor Grosvenor on his Web site: <<www.arthistorynews.com>>He concludes: “The {National Portait Gallery] need not fear embarrassment, however. I applaud the owner’s attempts to prove their painting is Jane. But I’m afraid these apparent inscriptions in old photos of the painting, which I have been shown, are (to me at least) not compelling. Nor is this the first time apparently conclusive ‘writing’ on the painting, seen in questionably interpreted and magnified old photographs, has been claimed. For the best critique of the painting’s identity, read former NPG chief curator Jacob Simon’s brief note here. In particular, he deals with the question of the apparent inscriptions written on the painting: The [Rice Portrait] website claims that the portrait is signed several times in monogram, inscribed JANE and dated 1788 but, from my lengthy experience of examining British portraits, these apppear to be purely incidental and meaningless markings. They were not noted by Thomas Harding Newman, owner of the portrait in 1880, who attributed it to Zoffany. They do not appear in photographs taken by Emery Walker in about 1910, despite claims to the contrary on the website. They were not apparent to the professional painting conservator who examined the portrait with others at Henry Rice’s request before cleaning it in 1985. They were not apparent to Christie’s experienced cataloguing staff in 2007 when the portrait was put up for sale in New York, despite an earlier report of initials on the portrait.

Posted 6/13/2012, 8:53:46pm by mrselsasol1

Leave a comment