00 Lawbreaker in Chief

Lawbreaker in Chief

Jennifer Granick

Ignorance of the law is no defense. Someone should tell the president.

This week, The New York Times revealed that the Bush administration ignored the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act, or FISA, and intercepted telephone calls and e-mails from American citizens without a warrant. FISA requires that investigators provide a judge with evidence that there’s reason to believe the person they plan to place under surveillance is an agent of a foreign power. Applications for these warrants are at an all-time high, and the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court (often called “the secret court”) almost never denies the requests.

Nonetheless, Bush has authorized the National Security Agency to ignore this relatively insignificant hurdle. The government has been monitoring calls to or from United States citizens to international locations, perhaps eavesdropping on as many as 500 people at any one time, according to the Times.

The surveillance policy is part of a larger Bush administration strategy that includes imprisoning people indefinitely without charges or attorneys in Guantanamo Bay and transporting suspects to countries known to torture, a process the administration calls “rendition.” As with these policies, the interceptions are almost certainly illegal.

Statutes prohibit government interceptions of the phone and e-mail conversations of United States citizens unless officials have first sought and obtained court approval, either under …. for national security investigations.

The only exceptions are following a declaration of war, when the president has very narrow, powers to order surveillance to obtain information to prevent attacks, terrorism or espionage, and under special circumstances when no U.S. citizens are involved. The administration’s actions clearly fall outside these boundaries.

There is no legal justification for these warrantless interceptions, which included calls to and from American citizens.

Nor is there any practical reason. FISA the attorney general to approve interceptions in an emergency, and gives up to 72 hours to seek court approval after the fact.

We won’t see a special prosecutor appointed to investigate these violations, though Bush has called for the Department of Justice to find out who informed the press of the illegal eavesdropping program. Apparently, informing the public that the NSA broke the law is more troubling to the president than breaking the law in the first place.

Instead, the administration claims that it has the power to ignore the law. Bush cites his authority under the Constitution, and Attorney General Alberto Gonzales cites Congress’ post-9/11 authorization for the administration to use force in combating terrorism. But even Gonzales admits that the resolution authorizing force said nothing about surveillance. He denies that his argument is just a convenient excuse for illegal behavior.

00 India Moon mission is ‘mixed success’

India Moon mission is ‘mixed success’

A crater on the moon photographer by Chandrayan-1

The mission’s objective was to map the resources of the Moon

India has abandoned its inaugural Moon mission, 10 months after it was launched. Science writer Pallava Bagla examines the mission’s performance.

So was India’s inaugural Moon mission a success or a failure?

Neither. By all accounts, it has been a mixed performance. Also, a definitive answer is not easy to give – it is possibly as grey as the surface of the Moon.

This was an expensive scientific experiment with many objectives and conducted in full public glare. Most engineering goals have been fulfilled, but pious promises to deliver “good science” from the mission are still to be met.

Big achievement

India launched its $100m unmanned space craft on 22 October 2008 from Sriharikota on the coast of the Bay of Bengal.

First, the spacecraft designed and built by the Indian Space Research Organisation (Isro) survived huge odds and successfully reached the Moon’s orbit.

This in itself was a big achievement since neither Russia or America succeeded in their maiden attempts; and there were several failures even before they got anywhere near the Moon.

So did India ride on the shoulders of earlier successes?

Certainly not, since the know-how and technologies to go to the Moon are just not available for the asking. Each nation has to learn on its own. India experimented and did that with complete success.

The only other country to have managed a similar maiden feat was China – its mission Chang’e-1 in 2007 lasted 16 months in space, according to the Chinese National Space Administration.

The Indian mission survived for about 10 months in space; most other missions to the Moon have been much more short-lived.

So did the Indian space agency, in its naivety, over-stretch and over-estimate the craft’s life when it planned for a 24-month mission?

Rocket carrying 10 satellites is launched from Sriharikota

The mission lasted 10 months in space

Possibly. The answer may emerge in the findings of the “failure analysis committee” that Isro has put in place after this debacle.

Despite being dubbed by Isro as an “engineering success”, the mission had a rough ride around the Moon.

A fuel leak from the rocket almost aborted its lift-off. Within days of reaching the Moon a power system failed, and a back-up system had to be activated.

Soon, the spacecraft started overheating due to the intense summer heat on the Moon. Isro scientists say it was deft mission management that saved it from a total burnout.

A few months into the mission the spacecraft lost its fine guidance system when the onboard “star sensor” packed up in the intense radiation around the Moon.

But, every time an instrument on this 1380kg robot gave way, mission controllers at Isro found an innovative solution to keep the mission alive.

Finally on 29 August 2009, the space agency lost all contact with Chandrayaan after a catastrophic failure – possibly in its power supply system. A day later the mission was “terminated”, although Isro chief G Madhavan Nair declared it had been a “complete success”.

‘Two-in-one mission’

The Indian mission was in certain respects much more challenging than the Chinese maiden lunar mission which was a simple national orbiter.

Chandrayaan-1 was literally a two-in-one mission, since the main satellite was to orbit at 100km above the Moon and then a tiny gadget the size of a computer monitor was to attempt a landing on the Moon surface.

The mission did this on 14 November 2008. No nation to date had succeeded in both a lunar orbiter and an impactor at the first attempt.

Madhavan Nair

Mr Nair says the mission is a ‘complete success’ (Photo: Pallava Bagla)

This was more than an experiment. It was also a brave global geo-political statement since the probe that crash landed on the Moon also permanently placed India’s flag on the Moon.

Having done this, India became the fourth nation to have done this after Russia, America and the European Space Agency.

This is hugely significant because, if ever the Moon’s resources are to be divided, India’s rightful share can be claimed having achieved what others have not been able to do.

There are many other firsts to this mission.

In a highly un-Indian trait, the Indian space agency delivered the Moon mission with no cost or time overrun at $100m and within eight years of it first being suggested.

The spacecraft carried 11 different sophisticated instruments, one of the largest suites of experiments ever carried to the Moon.

The objective was to remotely map the resources of the Moon, prepare a three-dimensional atlas of it and look for water.

All instruments worked for about 10 months in the hostile lunar environment. Dr Nair calls it a “more than 100% success of Indian technology”.

India also created a new model of international partnership.

On its own initiative India announced that it would be happy to piggyback instruments from global partners.

After a huge competition six instruments sourced from the European Space Agency (Esa), the National Aeronautics and Space Administration (Nasa) and Bulgaria were chosen.

Moon surface picture by Chandrayaan-1

Chandrayaan peered into the deepest craters searching for water

Bernard Foing, the chief scientist for Space Sciences at Esa calls the Indian mission “the first multi-continent, multi-country lunar mission ever to be undertaken”.

A little known fact is that India did not charge any money to fly these instruments 400,000km away: all got a free ride to the Moon, merely in exchange for sharing the scientific data.

Search for water

Chandrayaan-1 was also the first and the most detailed search for water on the Moon – to date water has never been found.

A miniature American radar onboard the Chandrayaan peered into the Moon’s deepest craters searching for “water ice”.

The Moon’s surface is so parched that scientists feel the only location where water could exist would be in the permanently shadowed craters on the lunar poles.

But these are so deep and dark that sunlight never reaches them – hence the only way to peep inside is to send a radar signal down into them.

The global collaborative team of the mission is very excited about the findings.

“Never seen before images of the permanently shadowed craters Moon have been captured,” says Paul D Spudis of the Lunar and Planetary Institute, Houston, USA and principal investigator of the payload sent to search for water.

“The new radar images are not only visually arresting, but they will be extremely useful in unravelling the complex geological history of the Moon as a whole,” he says.

Other scientific reports on findings are in the offing. But unless the results are published, questions will continue to be asked about whether the mission fulfilled its exalted scientific objectives.

The termination of the Moon mission will, however, not affect India’s plans in space.

The country is already planning a second mission to the Moon, Chandrayaan-2, with Russian collaboration in 2011-12; a mission to an asteroid; an unmanned mission to Mars in 2013 and a human space flight in 2015.

Upbeat Isro scientists are saying “Chandrayaan-1 is dead, long live Chandrayaan”. The jury will be out – until the scientific papers come in.

Pallava Bagla is the Science editor for New Delhi Television (NDTV) and author of the book Destination Moon – India’s quest for Moon, Mars and Beyond.

00 LUX Associate Artists Programme 2009/10

LUX Associate Artists Programme 2009/10

CALL FOR APPLICATIONS

Applications are invited for the LUX Associate Artists Programme (AAP), a 12 month post-academic development course for artists working with the moving image starting in November 2009.

The LUX Associate Artists Programme is for artists working with the moving image, who have completed a graduate or post-graduate course in the past five years. It aims to provide an intensive course of development focused on critical discourse, extending to the practical and infrastructural issues that present challenges for artists working with the medium. The course aims to provide a mutually supportive context in which to develop work, and to benefit from networking and learning opportunities with arts professionals closely involved in artists moving image, with funding to realise a final group project.

The programme consists of 12 monthly critical seminars taking place at LUX, exploring issues around artists’ moving image in the context of the artists’ own practice. The particular focus of each seminar will be decided by the participants in discussion with the programme facilitator, and each one will be based around an invited arts professional (artists, curators, writers etc). There will also be an informal programme of relevant events including access to LUX events during the year.

In addition, each artist will be paired with a mentor who they will meet with six times during the course. They will also have continuous access to specialist support from LUX staff and the programme facilitator during the year.

The programme is designed to be flexible and work around jobs and other commitments so most activity takes place in the evening and at weekends but applicants should be aware that the programme does involve a significant commitment over the course of the year.

The programme is free to participants, but they will be expected to cover their own costs such as travel.

Programme Aims
To create a mutually supportive context which places creative and intellectual practice at the heart of development.
To apply critical discourse as the main tool for achieving development.
To respect artists’ different working practices and to learn from each other’s development.
To explore social and cultural contexts as the location for significant individual practice.

The programme will be facilitated by Ian White, Adjunct Film Curator, Whitechapel Gallery.

Criteria for Selection
The Associate Artists Programme is aimed at artists resident in the UK who have completed a relevant course of graduate or post-graduate education in the last five years. (Artists do not need to be based in London although all the meetings will take place here so applicants should consider this).
In considering the applications the panel will be using the following criteria:
Applicant’s analysis of their own practice and professional trajectory.
Evidence of commitment to engage with the programme fully over the twelve months.
Evidence of intellectual enquiry which would form the basis of critical discourse.
Evidence that the applicant is receptive to considering conceptual and structural changes in their practice as a result of participation in the programme.

How to apply
Download and complete the application form and return with a CV and up to 2 moving image works (on DVD) which you feel best represent your current practice. Please return by post or hand (no email or fax please) to: AAP, LUX, 3rd Floor, Shacklewell Studios, 18 Shacklewell Lane, London, E8 2EZ. Please do not use recorded or special delivery as it will be returned to the sorting office. Please enclose a stamp-addressed envelope if you would like the DVD returned. Those who have applied unsuccessfully in previous years are encouraged to contact us to discuss their application in advance of submitting it.

DEADLINE FOR APPLICATIONS: Friday 18 September 2009 at 5pm

Download the AAP application form here

00 Man Lives 2nd Nightmare as His Molester Fakes Lawsuit

//www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/images/homepage/logos/twp_logo_300.gif” cannot be displayed, because it contains errors.

Man Lives 2nd Nightmare as His Molester Fakes Lawsuit
D.C. Judge Is Duped in Defamation Conspiracy Against Ohio Victim

By Del Quentin Wilber
Washington Post Staff Writer
Monday, August 24, 2009

The judgment stood for one day before unraveling. It was a plot so off the wall, so bizarre, that U.S. District Judge Richard J. Leon said it was “like something out of a novel.”

After serving a prison term for molesting an eighth-grader in Ohio, David Copeland-Jackson moved to the District to live with his mother. He e-mailed a buddy and together, federal authorities said, they came up with a plan that would fool a respected judge into issuing a $3 million defamation order against Copeland-Jackson’s victim.

Copeland-Jackson relied on forged documents, the victim’s unwitting assistance and the help of a 71-year-old paralegal who had become interested in his case. He even hired a handwriting expert and impersonated a private detective, authorities said.

Last month, a federal grand jury indicted Copeland-Jackson on charges of conspiring to commit perjury and obstruct justice. Copeland-Jackson, 36, of Southeast Washington, has pleaded not guilty.

Copeland-Jackson’s attorney, Robert Lee Jenkins Jr., said that his client was contrite and that “we are trying to resolve this matter by way of plea.” His mother said she can’t believe this is happening. “He would do anything for anybody,” Peggy Copeland said.

On Friday, his friend Peter J. Brandel, 71, of Mansfield, Ohio, pleaded guilty to conspiracy before Leon, whose facial expressions signaled increasing astonishment as the details tumbled out. Brandel faces up to 2 1/2 years in prison under federal guidelines at his sentencing in November.

The victim, Joseph Cutlip, now 24 and still living in Ohio, learned about the scheme only when it was too late — two years ago, when he received a court notice about the defamation suit in the mail. “My body felt numb,” Cutlip said. He was just getting over the trauma of the abuse, said Cutlip, who agreed to be named for this story. “It all sent me back into a deep depression. I just didn’t understand how he had taken advantage of me twice.”

To understand what happened, it helps to start at the beginning.

In 1999, Cutlip was an eighth-grader in Ashland, Ohio, and Copeland-Jackson, then 26, was one of his tutors. Copeland-Jackson molested Cutlip while helping the 14-year-old on a school project. He was convicted of two counts of gross sexual imposition of Cutlip and another boy and sentenced to three years in state prison, court records show.

While in an Ohio prison, he befriended Brandel, a paralegal who had learned about the case and believed that Copeland-Jackson had been wrongly accused, federal prosecutors said.

Copeland-Jackson was released from prison in late 2003. He changed his name legally to Xavier Justice in 2004, but he used both identities interchangeably and filed the federal suit under his original name, prosecutors said.

He moved to the District to live with his mother, and in 2006 he contacted Brandel and they started work on a scheme that they hoped would “coerce or fool” Cutlip into recanting his accusations, Assistant U.S. Attorney James Mitzelfeld wrote in court papers.

They soon settled on filing a federal defamation lawsuit. But first, federal prosecutors said, they needed Cutlip’s signature so they could forge the necessary court documents. Brandel filed a separate small-claims suit in April 2007, alleging that Cutlip had broken into his shed in Ohio and stolen tools and a barbecue grill, prosecutors said.

They knew the suit would go nowhere, prosecutors said, because Cutlip had been jailed on a separate burglary conviction when the tools were supposedly stolen from Brandel’s shed. But that was all part of the plan.

Cutlip quickly contested the suit, and Brandel arrived at his front door the next month to apologize, according to authorities. He told Cutlip that he needed his signature on documents to have the case dismissed. Cutlip signed the records in front of a notary public.

“I had no idea he was connected to” Copeland-Jackson, Cutlip said. “I was just happy to have that suit go away.”

In June, Copeland-Jackson filed his $3 million defamation of character lawsuit against Cutlip before U.S. District Judge Ellen S. Huvelle. He alleged that he was defamed by “false comments to third parties that [he] engaged in certain homosexual activities with” him.

Copeland-Jackson, who represented himself, soon filed court papers falsely claiming that the suit had been served on Cutlip, and Brandel signed an affidavit, under penalty of perjury, that he had handed the papers to Cutlip.

Copeland-Jackson then filed court papers in which Brandel swore that Cutlip had told him he was “sorry for lying” about the sex abuse accusations. Over the next few months, Copeland-Jackson even filed court papers on behalf of Cutlip — forging his signature on the documents — saying the allegations had been false and he didn’t wish to contest the defamation suit, federal prosecutors allege.

“I did not have any kind of sexual contact with David Copeland-Jackson,” Cutlip supposedly wrote in one document. “I willfully lied.”

Because the sex abuse case occurred in Ohio, Huvelle ordered Copeland-Jackson to explain why she had jurisdiction in the D.C. civil suit. That’s where Xavier Justice came in. Copeland-Jackson then filed an affidavit by a private investigator — Justice — who reported that Cutlip has family in the District and has lived here.

In a letter to Copeland-Jackson about his investigation that was filed in the case, Xavier Justice added an aside, apparently to make the document seem authentic. “Hit the gym this summer so you work out that stress,” Justice wrote to Copeland-Jackson.

Of course, federal prosecutors said, Xavier Justice actually was Copeland-Jackson.

In August 2007, Huvelle granted Copeland-Jackson the $3 million judgment. About that time, Cutlip first learned about the legal action after receiving a court notice in the mail that said he had lost a suit filed by Copeland-Jackson. Worried, Cutlip forwarded the letter to the local prosecutors’ office in Ohio, which immediately alerted Huvelle that Copeland-Jackson had molested Cutlip, was a registered sex offender and was on parole for the offense.

The judge also received a letter from a perplexed and upset Cutlip. “Would you please send me the paperwork on what Copeland-Jackson is suing me for,” he asked.

Huvelle quickly vacated the judgment, which stood for one day.

Cutlip said he is angry about what happened. The abuse wrecked his life, he said, and he later did a stint in prison. After learning about the suit, he said, he grew depressed, started drinking and lost his job. Now sober, he is looking for work but can’t get over his anger at Copeland-Jackson and hopes he gets a long prison term.

He is also upset with Huvelle. “If she had done any footwork at all, she would have known this was all bogus,” Cutlip said.

Huvelle declined to comment. At a hearing after learning about Copeland-Jackson’s actions in August 2007, she said she had referred the matter to federal authorities to investigate.

“I regret to say I was not astute enough to stop this,” she said at the time.

00 What’s Behind Birthers’ Obama Belief

August 10, 2009 | 73 comments

What’s Behind Birthers’ Obama Belief

Research done by Harvard’s Mahzarin Banaji and San Diego State’s Thierry Devos into what’s called “implicit social cognition” reveals that white Americans inherently regard white Europeans as somehow more “American” than Asian- or African-Americans, which may help explain why so many people find it easy to believe that President Obama is not really a citizen. Steve Mirsky reports

60-Second Science

Listen to this podcast:

Download this podcast
Subscribe via: RSS | iTunes
More 60-Second Science | All Podcasts


[The following is an exact transcript of this podcast.]

The so-called birthers can’t accept that President Obama is really a natural-born American citizen. Part of what’s behind this seemingly irrational belief may lie in what’s called implicit social cognition—the deep-rooted assumptions we all carry around, and may act on without realizing it.

Harvard’s Mahzarin Banaji studies such implicit cognition. Last fall she talked to journalists at the annual conference of the Council for the Advancement of Science Writing about research into bias against Asian-Americans. “So we thought, what if we picked Asians who are very well known to be American. What about Connie Chung? Are they going to be seen as less American than, let’s say, Hugh Grant? And so we thought this was a bizarre study to do but we did it anyway.”

Amazingly, white Americans did see a white European like Hugh Grant as being somehow more American than the Asian-American Connie Chung. And similar research in 2008 found that whites thought of ex-British Prime Minister Tony Blair as somehow more American than Obama. So the mental framework to believe that Obama is foreign probably was, to use a health care term, a preexisting condition.

—Steve Mirsky


60-Second Science is a daily Podcast. Subscribe to this Podcast: RSS | iTunes

00 The Wrong Diagnosis

\

Dr. Andrew Weil

Dr. Andrew Weil

Posted: August 9, 2009 11:00 PM

The Wrong Diagnosis

I’m worried — and if I’m worried, you should be, too.

The reason I’m worried is that the wrong diagnosis is being made.

As any doctor can tell you, the most crucial step toward healing is having the right diagnosis. If the disease is precisely identified, a good resolution is far more likely. Conversely, a bad diagnosis usually means a bad outcome, no matter how skilled the physician.

And, what’s true in personal health care is just as true in national health care reform: Healing begins with the correct diagnosis of the problem.

Washington is working on reform initiatives that focus on one problem: the fact that the system is too expensive (and consequently too exclusive.) Reform proposals, such as the “public option” for government insurance or calls for drug makers to drop prices, are aimed mostly at boosting affordability and access. Make it cheap enough, the thinking goes, and the 46 million Americans who can’t afford coverage will finally get their fair share.

But what’s missing, tragically, is a diagnosis of the real, far more fundamental problem, which is that what’s even worse than its stratospheric cost is the fact that American health care doesn’t fulfill its prime directive — it does not help people become or stay healthy. It’s not a health care system at all; it’s a disease management system, and making the current system cheaper and more accessible will just spread the dysfunction more broadly.

It’s impossible to make our drug-intensive, technology-centric, and corrupt system affordable. Consider that Americans spent $8.4 billion on medicine in 1950, vs. an astonishing 2.3 trillion in 2007. That’s $30,000 annually for a family of four. The bloated structure of endless, marginal-return tests; patent-protected drugs and “heroic” surgical interventions for virtually every health problem simply can’t be made much cheaper due to its very nature. Costs can only be shifted in various unpalatable ways.

So, a far more salient question that must be addressed is: Are we getting good health for our trillions? Unfortunately, the answer is a resounding, “No.” The U.S. ranked near the very bottom of the top 40 nations — below Columbia, Chile, Costa Rica and Dominica — in a rating of health systems by the World Health Organization in 2000. In short, we pay about twice as much per capita for our health care as does the rest of the developed world, and we have almost nothing to show for it.

I’m not against high-tech medicine. It has a secure place in the diagnosis and treatment of serious disease. But our health care professionals are currently using it for everything, and the cost is going to break us.

In the future, this kind of medicine must be limited to those cases in which it is clearly indicated: trauma, acute and critical conditions, disease involving vital organs, etc. It should be viewed as a specialized form of medicine, perhaps offered only in major centers serving large populations.

Most cases of disease should be managed in other, more affordable ways. Functional, cost-effective health care must be based on a new kind of medicine that relies on the human organism’s innate capacity for self-regulation and healing. It would use inexpensive, low-tech interventions for the management of the commonest forms of disease. It would be a system that puts the health back into health care. And it would also happen to be far less expensive than what we have now.

If we can make the correct diagnosis, the healing can begin. If we can’t, both our personal health and our economy are doomed.

Politicians aren’t going to resolve this issue overnight. Any health care reform bill that gets jammed through Congress in the next month or two will be dangerously flawed. Washington needs to take a step back and re-examine the entire task with an eye toward achieving the most effective solution, not the cheapest and most expeditious.

Dr Weil’s Vitamin Advisorwww.DrWeil.com
Recommendations from Dr Weil Based on your health concerns.

00 UN Address: Dialogue on the Responsibility to Protect, by Noam Chomsky

UN Address: Dialogue on the Responsibility to Protect

By Noam Chomsky

Noam Chomsky’s ZSpace Page
Join ZSpace

Address to the United Nations General Assembly Thematic Dialogue on the Responsibility to Protect, the United Nations, New York,  23 July 2009

The discussions about Responsibility to Protect (R2P), or its cousin “humanitarian intervention,” are regularly disturbed by the rattling of a skeleton in the closet: history, to the present moment.

Throughout history, there have been a few principles of international affairs that apply quite generally.  One is the maxim of Thucydides that the strong do as they wish, while the weak suffer as they must.  A corollary is what Ian Brownlie calls “the hegemonial approach to law-making”: the voice of the powerful sets precedents.

Another principle derives from Adam Smith’s account of policy-making in England: the “principal architects” of policy — in his day the “merchants and manufacturers” — make sure that their own interests are “most peculiarly attended to” however “grievous” the effect on others, including the people of England — but far more so, those who were subjected to “the savage injustice of the Europeans,” particularly in conquered India, Smith’s own prime concern.

A third principle is that virtually every use of force in international affairs has been justified in terms of R2P, including the worst monsters.  Just to illustrate, in his scholarly study of “humanitarian intervention,” Sean Murphy cites only three examples between the Kellogg-Briand pact and the UN Charter: Japan’s attack on Manchuria, Mussolini’s invasion of Ethiopia, and Hitler’s occupation of parts of Czechoslovakia, all accompanied by lofty rhetoric about the solemn responsibility to protect the suffering populations, and factual justifications.  The basic pattern continues to the present.  The historical record is worth recalling when we hear R2P or its cousin described as an “emerging norm” in international affairs.  They have been considered a norm as far back as we want to go.

The founding of this country is an example.  In 1629, the Massachusetts Bay Colony was granted its Charter by the King, stating that rescuing the natives from their bitter pagan fate is “the principal end of this plantation.” The Great Seal of the Colony depicts an Indian saying “Come Over and Help Us.” The English colonists were thus fulfilling their responsibility to protect as they proceeded to “extirpate” and “exterminate” the natives, in their words — and for their own good, their honored successors explained.  In 1630, John Winthrop delivered his famous sermon depicting the new nation “ordained by God” as “a city on a hill,” inspirational rhetoric that is regularly invoked to this day to justify any crime as at worst a “deviation” from the noble mission of responsibility to protect.

There is no difficulty adding similar examples from other great powers in their day in the sun.  It is understandable that the powerful should prefer to declare that we should forget history and look forward.  For the weak, it is not a wise choice.

The skeleton in the closet made an appearance in the first case considered by the International Court of Justice (ICJ) 60 years ago, the Corfu Channel case.  The Court determined that it “can only regard the alleged right of intervention as the manifestation of a policy of force, such as has, in the past, given rise to most serious abuses and such as cannot, whatever be the defects in international organization, find a place in international law. . .; from the nature of things, [intervention] would be reserved for the most powerful states, and might easily lead to perverting the administration of justice itself.”

The same perspective informed the first-ever meeting of the South Summit of 133 states, convened in April 2000.  Its declaration, surely with the bombing of Serbia in mind, rejected “the so-called ‘right’ of humanitarian intervention, which has no legal basis in the United Nations Charter or in the general principles of international law.” The wording reaffirms the important UN Declaration on Friendly Relations (UNGA Res. 2625, 1970). It has been repeated since, among others by the Ministerial Meeting of the Non-aligned Movement in Malaysia in 2006, again representing the traditional victims in Asia, Africa, Latin America, and the Arab world.

The same conclusion was drawn in 2004 by the high-level UN Panel on Threats, Challenges and Change.  The Panel adopted the view of the ICJ and the Non-aligned Movement, concluding that “Article 51 needs neither extension nor restriction of its long-understood scope.”  The Panel added that “For those impatient with such a response, the answer must be that, in a world full of perceived potential threats, the risk to the global order and the norm of nonintervention on which it continues to be based is simply too great for the legality of unilateral preventive action, as distinct from collectively endorsed action, to be accepted.  Allowing one to so act is to allow all” — which is, of course, unthinkable.

The same basic position was adopted by the UN World Summit in 2005.  While reaffirming stands that had already been accepted, the Summit also asserted the willingness “to take collective action . . . through the Security Council, in accordance with the Charter . . . should peaceful means be inadequate and national authorities are manifestly failing to protect their populations” from serious crimes.  At most, the phrase sharpens the wording of Article 42 on authorization for the Security Council to resort to force.  And it keeps the skeleton in the closet — if, and it is a large if, we can regard the Security Council as a neutral arbiter, not subject to the maxims of Thucydides and Adam Smith, a matter to which I will return.

There have been efforts to draw a sharp distinction between R2P and its cousin.  They may have some merit, but they go far beyond the evidence.  There is a good reason why “the right of humanitarian intervention” has been hotly contested, in substantial part along North-South lines, while R2P was affirmed — more accurately reaffirmed — by consensus at the Summit.  The reason is that the Summit acceptance of R2P rhetoric adds nothing substantially new.

The rights articulated in the crucial paragraphs 138 and 139 of the Summit declaration had not been seriously contested, and in fact had been affirmed and implemented, for example, with regard to apartheid South Africa.  Furthermore, the Security Council had already determined that it can even use force under Chapter VII to end massive human rights abuses, civil war, and violation of civil liberties: Resolutions 925, 929, 940, June-July 1994.  And as J. L. Holzgrefe observes, “most states are signatories to conventions that legally oblige them to respect the human rights of their citizens.” The few successes of R2P that have been widely hailed, as in Kenya, had no need for the Summit resolution, though the terminology of R2P was invoked.

In substance, R2P as formulated at the South Summit is a subcase of the “right of humanitarian intervention,” omitting the part that has been contested: the right to use force without Security Council authorization.  That does not imply that there is no significance to the more explicit focus on rights that had already been widely accepted.  The significance of the rhetorical shift will be determined by how it is implemented.  On that matter, there are few grounds for celebration.

There have been departures from the Corfu Channel restriction and its descendants.  The Constitutive Act of the African Union asserts “The right of the Union to intervene in a Member State . . . in respect of grave circumstances.”  That differs crucially from the Charter of the Organization of American States, which bars intervention “for any reason whatever, in the internal or external affairs of any other state.”  The reasons for the difference are clear.  The OAS Charter seeks to deter intervention by the “colossus of the North” — and has of course failed to do so.  But after the collapse of the apartheid states, the African Union faced no comparable problem.

If the African Union doctrine were to extend to the OAS or NATO, then they would be entitled to intervene within their own alliances.  That idea yields interesting and revealing conclusions about the OAS and NATO, which should not need elaboration.  But the conclusions would be inoperative, as in the recent past, thanks to the maxim of Thucydides.

I know of only one high-level proposal to extend R2P beyond the Summit consensus and the African Union extension, namely, in the Report of the International Commission on Intervention and State Sovereignty on Responsibility to Protect (2001).  The Commission considers the situation in which “the Security Council rejects a proposal or fails to deal with it in a reasonable time.”  In that case, the Report authorizes “action within area of jurisdiction by regional or sub-regional organizations under Chapter VIII of the Charter, subject to their seeking subsequent authorization from the Security Council” ((3) E, II).

At this point, the skeleton in the closet rattles quite loudly.  One reason is that the powerful unilaterally determine their own “area of jurisdiction.”  The OAS and AU cannot do so, but NATO can, and does.  NATO unilaterally determined that its “area of jurisdiction” includes the Balkans — but not NATO itself, where shocking crimes were committed against Kurds in southeastern Turkey through the 1990s, off the agenda because of the decisive military and diplomatic support for them by the Clinton administration, with the aid of other NATO powers.

NATO has also determined that its “area of jurisdiction” extends to Afghanistan, and beyond.  Secretary-General Jaap de Hoop Scheffer informed a NATO meeting in June 2007 that “NATO troops have to guard pipelines that transport oil and gas that is directed for the West,” and more generally have to protect sea routes used by tankers and other “crucial infrastructure” of the energy system.  The expansive rights accorded by the International Commission are in practice restricted to NATO alone, radically violating the principles of Corfu Channel and its descendants, and opening the door for resort to R2P as a weapon of imperial intervention at will.

The Corfu Channel principle provides considerable insight into both the timing of the rhetorical invocation of R2P and its cousin, and the selectivity of their application in this new incarnation.  The “normative revolution” declared by Western commentators took place in the 1990s, immediately after the collapse of the Soviet Union, which had, in earlier years, provided an automatic pretext for intervention.

The Bush senior administration reacted to the fall of the Berlin Wall with an official exposition of Washington’s new course: in brief, everything will stay much the same, but with new pretexts.  We still need a huge military system, but for a new reason: the “technological sophistication” of third world powers.  We have to maintain the “defense industrial base” — a euphemism for state-supported high-tech industry.  We must maintain intervention forces directed at the Middle East energy-rich regions — where the threats to our interests that required military intervention “could not be laid at the Kremlin’s door,” contrary to decades of pretense.  New pretexts for intervention were needed, and the “normative revolution” entered the stage — once again.

The natural interpretation of the timing gains support from the selectivity of application of R2P.  There was of course no thought of applying the principle to the Iraq sanctions administered by the Security Council, condemned as “genocidal” by the two directors of the oil-for-food program, Denis Halliday and Hans von Sponeck, both of whom resigned in protest. Von Sponeck’s detailed study of the horrendous impact of the sanctions has been under a virtual ban in the US and UK, the primary agents of the programs.

Similarly, there is no thought today of protection of the people of Gaza, also a UN responsibility, along with the rest of the “protected population” (under the Geneva Conventions), denied fundamental human rights.  Nothing serious is contemplated about the worst catastrophe in Africa, if not the world: Eastern Congo, where only a few days ago, BBC reported, multinationals are once again being accused of violating a UN resolution against illicit trade of valuable minerals and thus funding the murderous conflict.

In another domain, there is no thought of invoking even the most innocuous prescriptions of R2P to respond to massive starvation in the poor countries.  The UN recently estimated that the number of those facing hunger has passed a billion, while the World Food Program of the UN has just announced major cutbacks of aid because the rich countries are reducing their meager contributions, giving priority to bailing out banks. Several years ago UNICEF reported that 16,000 children die every day from lack of food, many more from easily preventable disease.  The figures are higher now.  In southern Africa alone, it is Rwanda-level killing, not for 100 days, but every day.  There is surely ample warning, but no thought of action under R2P, though it would be easy enough if the will were there.

In these and numerous other cases the selectivity conforms with painful precision to the maxim of Thucydides, and the expectations of the ICJ 60 years ago.

Perhaps the most striking illustration of the consistent radical selectivity was in 1999, when NATO bombed Serbia, an attack featured in Western discourse as the jewel in the crown of the “emerging norm” of humanitarian intervention, when the US was at the “height of its glory” in leading the “enlightened states,” and the “idealistic New World bent on ending inhumanity” opened a new era in history by acting on “principles and values,” to cite just a few of the accolades by Western intellectuals.

There are a few difficulties confronting this flattering self-image.  One problem is that the traditional victims of Western intervention vigorously objected.  I have already quoted the stand of the Non-aligned movement; Nelson Mandela was particularly harsh in his condemnation.  That was unproblematic: the views of the unworthy are easily ignored.

Furthermore, the bombing plainly violated the UN Charter.  That problem too was easily put to rest.  Some resorted to legalistic maneuvering, but as the Goldstone Commission more forthrightly determined, the bombing was “illegal but legitimate,” a conclusion reached by reversing the chronology of bombing and atrocities.

That leads to a third problem: the facts, which happen to be richly documented from impeccable Western sources.  What they reveal is unequivocal.  The NATO bombing did not end the atrocities but rather precipitated by far the worst of them, as had been anticipated by the NATO command and the White House.  The conclusions that are so richly documented by the Western records are reinforced by the indictment of Miloševic, issued by the International Tribunal at the height of the bombing.

With a single exception, the crimes charged follow the bombing.  And we can be confident that the one pre-bombing charge — the Racak massacre — was of little principled concern to the US and Britain, if only because at the very same time they were not merely condoning but actively supporting much more serious crimes in East Timor, where the background of atrocities was incomparably more grotesque than anything that had happened in the Balkans.  And that is only one of many examples right at that time.  This problem too was overcome quite simply: by virtual suppression of the ample record.

The case of East Timor is particularly instructive.  On a personal note, I testified about it at the Fourth Committee in 1978, when atrocities reached the level of “extermination as a crime against humanity committed against the East Timorese population,” in the words of the later UN-sponsored Truth Commission, and Britain and France joined the US in supporting them, along with Australia and others, continuing to do so right through 1999 as atrocities sharply mounted again.  After the final paroxysm of state terror in September 1999, which destroyed most of what remained of the country, National Security Adviser Sandy Berger said that the US would continue its support for the aggressors, explaining that “I don’t think anybody ever articulated a doctrine which said that we ought to intervene wherever there’s a humanitarian problem.” R2P vanished in the familiar way.

To end the atrocities in this case would not have required bombing, or sanctions, or indeed any act beyond withdrawal of participation.  That was demonstrated shortly after Berger’s reaffirmation of Western policy, when, under strong domestic and international pressure, Clinton formally ended US participation.  The invaders immediately withdrew, and a UN peacekeeping force was able to enter facing no army.  That could have been done any time in the preceding quarter-century.  Astonishingly, this horrendous story was soon reinterpreted as vindication of R2P, a reaction so shameful that words fail.

I mentioned that the consensus of the World Summit adheres to the Corfu principle and its descendants only if we assume that the Security Council is a neutral arbiter.  It plainly is not.  The Council is controlled by its five permanent members, and they are not equal in operative authority.  One indication is the record of vetoes — the most extreme form of violation of a Security Council Resolution.  The relevant period is from the mid-1960s, when decolonization and recovery from wartime destruction gave the UN at least some standing as representative of world opinion.  Since then, the US is far in the lead in vetoes, Britain second, no one else even close.  In the past quarter-century, China and France vetoed 3 resolutions, Russia four, the UK ten, and the US 43, including even resolutions calling on states to observe international law.  The skeleton in the closet nods in recognition as the maxim of Thucydides strikes again.

One way to mitigate this defect in the World Summit consensus would be to eliminate the veto — incidentally, in accord with the will of most Americans, who believe that the US should follow the will of the majority and that the UN, not the US, should take the lead in international crises.  But here we run up against Adam Smith’s maxim, which ensures that such heresies are unthinkable, as much so as applying R2P right now to those who desperately need protection but are not on the favored list of the powerful. American public opinion brings up a further consideration.  The maxims that largely guide international affairs are not graven in stone, and, in fact, have become considerably less harsh over the years as a result of the civilizing effect of popular movements.  For that continuing and essential project, R2P can be a valuable tool, much as the Universal Declaration of Human Rights has been.

Even though states do not adhere to the UDHR, and some formally reject much of it (crucially including the world’s most powerful state), nonetheless it serves as an ideal that activists can appeal to in educational and organizing efforts, often effectively.  My suspicion is that a major contribution of the discussion of R2P may turn out to be rather similar, and with sufficient commitment, unfortunately not yet detectable among the powerful, it could be significant indeed.


Noam Chomsky is Institute Professor and Professor of Linguistics Emeritus at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology.  Among his recent books is Inside Lebanon: Journey to a Shattered Land with Noam and Carol Chomsky (Monthly Review Press, 2007).  Download Chomsky’s speech in PDF: <un.org/ga/president/63/interactive/protect/noam.pdf>. javascript:HaloScan(‘chomsky030809’);



From: Z Net – The Spirit Of Resistance Lives
URL: http://www.zcommunications.org/znet/viewArticle/22227

00 Locus Amoenus, Carlos Alvar y Jenaro Talens en Galaxia Gutenberg

‘Locus amoenus’. Antología de la lírica medieval de la Península Ibérica

La lírica es una forma de expresión que continúa dando muestras de una espléndida vitalidad. Una de las muchas pruebas de ello es el hecho de que durante estos últimos meses hayan coincidido en las librerías españolas tres muestras de tan hondo calado como pueden ser el volumen dedicado a los Manrique (Fundación Castro), los 1.000 Años de poesía europea (edición de Francisco Rico para Backlist) o este Locus Amoenus que ofrecen ahora Carlos Alvar y Jenaro Talens en Galaxia Gütenberg. Tres verdaderas joyas y otros tantos motivos para felicitarnos de que, a día de hoy, haya gente contemporánea que sigue haciendo posible disfrutar del legado dejado por unos antepasados que en cierto modo también son nuestros contemporáneos. O al menos muy próximos y solidarios porque, novecientos años después, sus sentimientos siguen siendo los nuestros. Ellos ya pasaron por aquí y, lo dicen con su canción, también hay lugar para el gozo.

Jenaro Talens, catedrático de Literatura Hispánica, traductor y poeta, y Carlos Alvar, Catedrático de Literatura Española medieval y del Renacimiento, y también traductor, ofrecen una copiosa antología de la lírica medieval producida en España entre la desaparición del Imperio Romano y la eclosión del Renacimiento. Todo un viaje que empieza con la poesía amorosa latina conservada en el Cancionero de Ripoll y que luego sigue con muestras de la poesía árabe, poseedora ésta de una imaginería límpida y certera pero del todo ajena a la tradición grecolatina: “¡De cuántas casas fui la lluvia durante la sequía!”, exclama el guerrero malherido y cuyo único consuelo frente a la muerte que está arrancándole el alma es que dentro de ésta siente “un amor que hace más llevadero verse privado de la vida”. Es decir, lo mismo solo que dicho de forma diferente. El paso sucesivo a la poseía hebrea, mozárabe, provenzal, galaico-portuguesa, catalana y castellana (que constituye el grueso de la antología, aparte del hecho de que todas las demás lenguas han sido traducidas al castellano) constituye un fascinante recorrido por la otredad y permite hacerse una idea muy exacta de lo que debía ser la Península Ibérica antes de que se impusiera el invento de esa entelequia escondida tras el término España.

La imagen de variedad y riqueza que transmite este Locus Amoenus es tanto más meritoria cuanto que al hablar de esas ocho lenguas localizadas en un espacio común, y en algunos casos contemporáneamente, suele utilizarse la palabra “coexistencia”, la cual, a su vez, sugiere la idea de “pacífica”. Coexistencia pacífica. Pero nada más lejos de la realidad. No es preciso evocar aquí el largo y sangriento contencioso entre moros y cristianos. Ni la proverbial tendencia de los hebreos a entrar en conflicto con los pueblos que los acogen en su diáspora, o el interminable rosario de alianzas y traiciones que se desgrana de la historia de las naciones.  Pero curiosamente, incluso en una situación de conflicto y cohabitación forzada o contra natura, el ser humano ha dado muestras sobradas de su capacidad de superación y su espíritu creativo, y ahí están aquellos catalanes haciendo uso de la lengua de oc, de los castellanos rimando en gallego, los portugueses expresándose en castellano, o, escándalo de los escándalos, un hebreo educado por los árabes (Moshé ibn Ezrá) que escribía poesía en hebreo pero utilizando la métrica y la imaginería habitual árabes. Aunque no es menos escandaloso  el ejemplo de aquellos grandes señores castellanos que al empuñar la pluma desdeñaban la lengua que hizo grandes a Ovidio o Cicerón en favor del habla tosca y rudimentaria que usaban sus vasallos y sus soldados.  Obviamente, quienes así obraban no sólo no pusieron en peligro la conservación de la tradición de Occidente sino que sentaron las bases para que, no mucho después, gente como Cervantes o Santa Teresa pudiesen decir lo que tenían que decir.

Como señalan los propios autores en el prólogo “toda aproximación a la poesía hispánica medieval debe asumir que las varias e irreductibles líneas de fuerza que la atraviesan no pueden ser integradas en un universo unitario y todo intento de articular lo diferente como variante de una cierta multiplicidad de lo mismo no hace sino perpetuar una prioridad jerárquica, que, no por casualidad, corresponde a quien está en uso de la palabra”. Por si alguien la necesitaba, este libro es una prueba más de que el Espíritu tiene sus propias vías de expresión y que tratar de confinarlo a una sola lengua es inútil, con la particularidad de que si esto que digo es cierto seguirá siéndolo si en lugar del castellano recurro al euskera, al gallego, al catalán o al bable.

Locus amoenus
Antología de la lírica medieval
de la Península Ibérica
Edición bilingüe de Carlos Alvar y Jenaro Talens.
Galaxia Gütenberg

[Publicado el 27/7/2009 a las 10:45]

00 Why We Need a Bold Vision for Preserving Our Wilderness

Robert Redford

Robert Redford

Posted: July 27, 2009 01:01 PM

Why We Need a Bold Vision for Preserving Our Wilderness

I have welcomed several promising signs coming out of the Obama Administration, from the president’s push for clean energy to Interior Secretary Salazar’s efforts to block oil and gas leasing near some of Utah’s most stunning landscapes.

But there is still something I am waiting to see: a bold new vision for preserving America’s wilderness.

Why does wilderness matter right now? It matters to me personally because I believe that our last public wilderness areas, with their rugged beauty, uncharted terrain, and ability to test human strength, are essential symbols of the American spirit.

But it also matters legally. According to the Wilderness Act of 1964, once a landscape has been altered by human development–including natural gas pipelines, oil drill heads, or roads for seismic thumper trucks–it can never become a protected wilderness area.

This is exactly the cynical calculus the Bush administration used to convert America’s public lands into money-making ventures for a few energy companies.

Unlike any administration before it, the Bush White House claimed it had no legal requirement to protect wilderness lands, and so for eight long years, it refused to do so. Millions of acres of wilderness-quality lands were stripped of protection and opened for energy development.

We lost so much ground during the Bush administration, and we are still feeling the aftershocks: leasing, drilling permits, and off-road vehicle plans continue to be approved and destroy wilderness lands in my beloved Utah and elsewhere (see threatened areas on this map).

Secretary Salazar can change this. He can craft a new vision for preserving and managing the public’s wilderness. I am hopeful that Salazar can take this step. He has spoken many times of his commitment to America’s “treasured landscapes,” but I encourage him to single out and prioritize our wilderness areas.

Because unlike other pieces of our national heritage–monuments such as the Lincoln Memorial or documents like the original Declaration of Independence–America’s wilderness is not complete or set in stone. It can be added to, and deciding which landscapes should be preserved for posterity is an ongoing process.

This gives Salazar a great opportunity to expand the public’s inheritance, because in fact, neither Salazar nor the Obama administration owns these lands. The American people do, and it is ours to treasure and enjoy.

I myself cherish the wildlands of Utah, like the Dark Canyon Wilderness Area, whose castle-like walls reach toward Glen Canyon, or the Paria Canyon-Vermilion Cliffs Wilderness, home to pink and red slot canyons so artfully sculpted it seems like they were carved by hand.

These are magical places that I have explored with my family. But I have also seen far too many wildlands lost forever. Places I viewed as symbols of this so-called Promised Land have disappeared into clear cuts, drilling fields, and open-pit mines. What do our children inherit from this irretrievable loss? Pictures of how it used to be?

Wallace Stegner wrote that you do not have to travel to a wilderness area to know that it is worth saving–simply knowing such a wild sanctuary exists is enough to create a geography of hope.

We can know, without ever going to the Dark Canyon or Vermilion Cliffs, that fellow Americans had the foresight to protect something wild in our landscape–and maybe in our national character–for generations to come.

We have the responsibility to do the same for our children. And I hope Secretary Salazar will lead the way.

You can encourage him by clicking here and sending him a letter about protecting our remaining wilderness.

00 Wall Street on Speed

Robert Kuttner

Robert Kuttner

Posted: July 26, 2009 09:19 PM

Wall Street on Speed

The New York Times recently reported that the latest scheme–or scam–on Wall Street is something called High Frequency Trading. Very sophisticated financial firms, such as Goldman Sachs, are tipped off by the New York Stock Exchange’s own computers to pending buy and sell orders. Armed with ultra sophisticated computer algorithms, the insiders anticipate the direction of the market based on what they learn about supply and demand for a given security. They can make an extra penny here and an extra penny there at the expense of us suckers, adding up to billions.

“Nearly everyone on Wall Street is wondering how hedge funds and large banks like Goldman Sachs are making so much money so soon after the financial system nearly collapsed,” wrote the Times‘ Charles Duhigg in a front page piece that was the talk of New York and Washington. “High-frequency trading is one answer.”

As debates in the blogosphere in the last couple of days have made clear, there are a couple of possibilities of what is at work here. One is that Goldman and others are literally using privileged information to make trades ahead of markets, in which case they are committing a felony. Specifically, the abuse is known as “front-running,” or trading ahead of customers, and it is an explicitly illegal form of market manipulation. Front running is epidemic on Wall Street–the whole point of an investment bank trading for its own account is to take advantage of its specialized knowledge of markets–and the SEC or the Justice Department shuts down front-running when it becomes too blatant to ignore.

The other possibility is that the Goldmans of the world have found themselves a nice loophole. Tapping into the Stock Exchange’s own computers and other sources of trading activity is something that anyone in theory could do, but only a few privileged insiders have the sophistication to exploit what they find. Often orders are placed, only to be cancelled. Their purpose is to figure out what the market is willing to pay, and then get in ahead of it.

But suppose that High Frequency Trading doesn’t violate any law. It still is the essence of what’s wrong with the recent metastasis of money markets into private game preserves for insider-traders.

Consider for a moment some first principles. The legitimate and efficient function of financial markets is to connect investors to entrepreneurs, and depositors to borrowers. There is no legitimate reason whatever for this to be done by the millisecond. At bottom, the process is pretty simple. The intermediary–the bank, savings institution, or investment bank makes its fees for making a judgment about risk and reward. How likely is the loan to be paid back? How high an interest rate should it charge? How should a new issue of securities be priced? The investor decides whether to indulge a taste for risk or for prudence.

But the hyperactive trading markets and creations of recent decades such as credit default swaps and high speed trading algorithms add nothing to the efficiency of financial markets. They add only two things–risk to the system, and the opportunity for insiders to reap windfall profits.

Therefore, whether or not Goldman’s lawyers have figured out how it can engage in High Frequency Trading and stay within the law, there is a strong case that this entire brand of financial engineering should be prohibited. The whole game should be slowed down. Bona fide investors should get in line under the rule of first come, first served. Anything else should be considered illegal market manipulation. No dummy transactions. There is absolutely no gain to economic efficiency from having prices of securities change in milliseconds, and much gain to the opportunities for manipulation.

The need to restrain traders from exploiting their privileged knowledge is an old fight. During the New Deal, for example, many reformers proposed that floor specialists for investment bankers and brokerage houses simply be prohibited from trading for their own accounts. They should be there simply to execute buy and sell orders for customers. Otherwise, the conflict of interest would be overwhelming–and this was before computers. These reformers were overruled, but insider trading was explicitly prohibited (and good luck catching it.)

Now, as then, it is a mark of Wall Street’s stranglehold on politics that the most sensible of remedies seem impossibly radical. One very good way to damp down the dictatorship of the traders, and raise some needed revenue along the way, would be through a punitively high transactions tax on very short term trades. Genuine investors should get favored fax treatment. Pure traders should be taxed, and very short term manipulation taxed into oblivion.

If the financial crisis has proven anything, it is that capital markets have become an insiders’ game in which trading profits crowd out the legitimate business of investment. The whole business-models of the most lucrative firms on Wall Street are a menace to the rest of the economy. Until the Obama administration recognizes this most basic abuse and shuts it down, it will be more enabler than reformer.
Robert Kuttner is co-editor of The American Prospect, and a senior fellow at Demos. His recent book is Obama’s Challenge.

00 Immigrants: the new, high-tech entrepreneurs

Reuters Blogs

Entrepreneurial

Grow your own

July 22nd, 2009

Immigrants: the new, high-tech entrepreneurs

Posted by: Lara Hertel
Tags: Trading Places, Uncategorized, , , , , ,

immigrants2

Picture the founders of any big-name tech company in the U.S. and you’ll probably think of Twitter’s Biz Stone, or Apple’s  Steve Jobs, or Bill Gates from Microsoft.

In other words: white American men.

But a report released this month reveals that 16 percent of high-tech, “high-impact” companies are founded by immigrants.

The study, commissioned by the self-proclaimed “business watchdog” Office of Advocacy of the U.S. Small Business Administration, is significant for a couple reasons. For one, consider the term “high-impact,” which describes firms with sales that have at least doubled over the most recent 4-year period, with notable employment growth. These aren’t fledgling gadget companies with no hope for survival.

Even more importantly, the research underlines the vital role U.S. immigration policy plays in entrepreneurialism — particularly in light of growing competition from emerging economies like China.  As the study points out, immigrant entrepreneurialism isn’t just on the rise, it’s driving job creation in a key industry and growth in the U.S. economy.

But immigration policy has some cracks in it, and it could be costly.  Says the study:

“Even those individuals who have a reasonable prospect of extending their stay in the United States may lack the certainty that they will be here long enough to be able to reap the benefits of taking the entrepreneurial ‘leap’ because of the way the immigration system handles their cases. As a result, their potential entrepreneurial contribution to the nation may be lost.”

One final note about immigrant entrepreneurs, lest anyone think they’re swooping into the U.S. to make a fortune before they fly the coop: a big chunk of them have been in this country for two decades or more, more than three-quarters of them are U.S. citizens, and two-thirds of them received undergraduate or graduate degrees in the U.S.

Is the U.S. doing enough to foster entrepreneurialism?  Share your thoughts below.

00 French Teachers Rally Against New Rules

French Teachers Rally Against New Rules
Government Mandate on Classwork Is Seen as an Attack on Long-Held Ideals

By Edward Cody
Washington Post Foreign Service
Saturday, July 11, 2009

TOULOUSE, France, July 10 — Alain Refalo, a veteran elementary schoolteacher in this luxuriant corner of southwestern France, decided enough was enough.

In a defiant letter to local authorities, he refused to carry out a new Education Ministry rule mandating extra classroom work for slow learners because, in his view, it would overtax his young charges. Worse, he explained in an interview, the orders from Paris seemed to be part of a trend inching French schools away from some of their most cherished ideals, making them resemble something in England or even America.

“I told myself I could not do things that were against my conscience,” Refalo said.

For his defiance, Refalo, 45, spent eight hours Thursday before a ministry disciplinary council here, risking demotion or suspension in a punishment that officials said would be handed down in a few days. But he was not alone. Since Refalo wrote his letter Nov. 6, more than 2,800 French schoolteachers have issued similar declarations; they have become what they describe as an unprecedented civil disobedience movement against the ministry’s efforts to change some of the ways French elementary school students are taught.

The revolt, although involving a minuscule proportion of the country’s 350,000 such educators, has dramatized anew how deeply France cherishes its traditions and how ready its people are to resist what they see as attacks on a way of life and a set of ideals that they know and trust. The issue has become particularly sensitive since the rise to power of President Nicolas Sarkozy, who was elected in May 2007 on a pledge to break with the past and push French society into a globalized 21st century.

As the teachers saw it, at stake in Toulouse was a concept of universal public schooling that has informed what happens in French classrooms ever since it was defined by Jules Ferry, an education minister in the late 19th century. Basically, it established that elementary schools should be government-run, free for anybody and ready to teach the same thing at the same time, so children everywhere across France have an equal chance at success.

Concern that those ideals might be compromised inspired widespread opposition to several other education reforms proposed last year by Sarkozy’s business-oriented government. The opposition, from students and professors alike, generated fears of turmoil in the streets and forced Sarkozy to pull back plans for changes in secondary schools last winter, then in universities in the spring.

Undaunted, Sarkozy replaced his education and higher education ministers in a recent government shakeup and vowed to push ahead. But the message from teachers and students was clear — so clear that Sarkozy the reformer, elected on a promise of rupture with tradition, two weeks ago praised the merits of the “French model” in a speech at Versailles Palace marked by monarchical trappings from the time of Louis XIV.

Sarkozy’s plan to relax the ban against work on Sunday has encountered similar resistance. Many French have refused to contemplate giving up the long-held tradition that Sunday is for family, long lunches and afternoon strolls, even if it means earning less money.

Against that background, Mayor Pierre Cohen of Toulouse, who also is a member of parliament from the opposition Socialist Party, joined several hundred teachers and parents in a demonstration Thursday to support Refalo. Cohen, to cheers from an appreciative crowd, said the attempt to punish Refalo was part of a general campaign waged by Sarkozy against French public servants and the long-standing tradition of heavy government involvement in the society.

“The republic as we know it, is in danger,” agreed Martin Malvy, president of the regional council and a fellow Socialist who also showed up to offer Refalo his support.

Refalo, a slight man with a boyish face and swept-back hair, has taught for years at Jules Ferry Elementary School in the Toulouse suburb of Colomiers. He opposes a new rule instituted last fall calling on teachers to do two hours a week of remedial work with failing students, declaring that youngsters cannot work fruitfully after a six-hour classroom day. Moreover, he pointed out, the ministry had just announced budget cuts in which 3,000 special education teachers were being eliminated — and whose jobs were to help students in difficulty.

The planned layoffs were part of a program set in motion by Sarkozy in which only one of every two civil servants who resigns is replaced, an effort to reduce the burdensomely high number of government employees. The Education Ministry announced that the jobs of 16,000 teachers and other national school system employees would be eliminated over the next school year.

But running beneath the specific complaint, Refalo said, was a general impression that the ideals of good citizenship in French education as laid down by Ferry were being eroded. Ideas such as competition, individualist thinking, privatization and survival of the fittest were being introduced, he asserted, ushering French youngsters toward a set of principles resembling those of England or the United States.

“This government applies to schools the good old recipes of a market economy,” he said to supporters this month. “We are witnessing with our own eyes a creeping privatization of public schools. But there is something much more important and even more revolting; it is the change in values imposed by this liberal ideology.”

Instead of doing remedial work, Refalo used the extra time to organize theater workshops, with an eye to encouraging his 10-year-old pupils to express themselves and to delve into literature. He published his letter and several other declarations on an Internet site called “pedagogical resistance.”

After several visits from ministry inspectors, he was formally accused of disobedience, violating confidentiality, inciting disobedience and publicly attacking an Education Ministry official in his writings.

Local teachers unions, while avoiding endorsing Refalo’s civil disobedience, have urged the ministry not to punish him, as have several nationally known education figures. But the new education minister, Luc Chatel, made it clear he would maintain his predecessor’s determination to put the rebel through disciplinary procedures. “Disobedience seems to me not very compatible with the job of teacher,” Chatel said in a radio interview. “He incarnates authority, so there would be a real paradox if he didn’t apply his own rules.”

But three prominent members of the French Resistance against Nazi occupation during World War II issued an open letter this month supporting Refalo and reminding the government that heeding authority is not always the best solution. “We wish to bear witness that there are moments in the life of a man when it is an imperious necessity to assume his convictions and share them with others,” said Raymond Aubrac, Walter Bassan and Stephane Hessel.

00 OBAMA AND PRESIDENT MEDVEDEV OF RUSSIA

THE BRIEFING ROOM

THE WHITE HOUSE

Office of the Press Secretary
____________________________________________________________
For Immediate Release                                       July 6, 2009

PRESS CONFERENCE
BY PRESIDENT OBAMA
AND PRESIDENT MEDVEDEV OF RUSSIA

The Kremlin
Moscow, Russia

7:21 P.M. (Local)

PRESIDENT MEDVEDEV:  (As translated.)  Distinguished ladies and gentlemen, ladies and gentlemen of the press, colleagues, we have just completed our negotiations with the U.S. President.  The first visit of U.S. President Barack Obama in Russia was a very busy one.  The first day showed that we managed to discuss all the items of our agenda, and it was a very big one.

I would like from the outset to say that there was a very useful and very open business-like conversation.  This, no doubt, was a meeting that has been expected, both in this country and the United States of America, and on which not only the future of our two country depends but also, to a large extent, the trends of world development.

I would like to emphasize once again, of course, the first day of negotiations, our meeting in — one on one and in a limited composition and a larger composition were very open and sincere.  And this is extremely important.  We have agreed that we will continue to communicate in this mode further on.  In reality, for our relations, it is very important and it is not a simple job, because the backlog of problems is quite impressive.

But we have enough of mutual wish and will and the positions of principles that we have always occupied and still occupy, to make the discussion of these problems in a business-like manner.  And we have reached mutually beneficial results.

I would like to emphasize that each of our countries understand its role in its own way, but at the same time we realize our role and responsibility for the situation in this world — especially in a period when the level of globalization has reached such dimensions and such parameters that the decisions we make very often determine the situation in general.  And such powerful states as the United States of America and the Russian Federation have special responsibility for everything that is happening on our planet.

We have many points of convergence, many mutual interests, and global and economic ones and a variety of other interests.  But our desire to discuss these subjects was mutual and this is also one of very important results of our meeting since the work we are doing requires goodwill, mutual respect, and honest understanding of each other’s position.

We also came to the conclusion that Russian-American relations and the level achieved today does not correspond to their potential, to the other possibilities of our countries.  And the important thing is that the level that we have today does not correspond to the need of the current age, and without active development of our relations on the foreign affairs agenda, on scientific, trade, educational, relations will not be able to build the road to the 21st century.

We have spent several hours in very busy negotiations, very specific, and at the same we dwelled on the questions of philosophy of our cooperation.  I’m grateful to the President of the United States for the understanding he showed on the principles that we put forward and our attention to the proposals made by the American side.  So despite of the fact that in several hours we cannot remove the burden of all the problems, we have agreed that we will go forward without stopping; that we will make the decisions that are needed for the development of relations between our two countries.

We have discussed quite specific problems, and I would like to share some of them with you.  We, of course, discussed international subjects.  We spoke about such difficult problems as the process of Middle East settlement.  We agreed to continue our work, taking into account the visits we had in the Middle East recently, and the plans that we discussed.  We discussed the possibility of holding Moscow conference on the Middle East.
We spoke about a very important subject that is extremely — requires the coordination of our activities.  This is the problem of Afghanistan.  Without our joint work in that area, we would not be able to achieve success in that area, and on that score we have agreed on a special statement.

Our relations will be also consolidated by our links in the humanitarian field, in the field of science.  This has to be done by all means, and we’ll be dealing with this after this meeting in a very persistent way.

Now, a few specific results of our negotiations.  You are aware of them.  We have agreed on a very important subject, the new agreement of strategic offensive arms.  So this is a basic element of our mutual security.  The work was very intensive and I must admit that our teams, our delegations, worked on this subject in a very fruitful way.  They have showed reasonable compromise, and I would like to thank everyone who took part in these negotiations or is going to take part in them.

A result of this is that we have reached not only mutual understanding of what — how we should move forward, but also to the basic levels on which we will advance our cooperation in those fields.  We agreed on the levels of carriers and warheads, meaning that this is a very concrete subject.

In the mutual understanding, as we have just signed with the President of the United States, it is said that our two countries can have from 500 to 1,100 carriers of strategic arms, and from 1,500 to 1,675 warheads.  These are the new parameters within which our dialogue will be going on and where we hope to achieve final agreement that will be part of the new treaty.

We have agreed also that the offensive and defensive systems of both countries should be considered together.  We have adopted a joint statement on ABM.  And this is also an important result of our work, even taking into account that we have divergences on a number of items.  Nevertheless, we managed to sign — to approve a joint document.

We have discussed measures of cooperation in the nuclear field and the most important is that we will continue our cooperation in every area, and a lot depends on our countries.  We have signed an agreement on military transit to Afghanistan.  We decided to create a presidential commission on cooperation, which will be coordinating relations among various agencies of the United States and the Russian Federation, respectively, in all priority areas, including economic and military areas.

In the military area, these questions will be dealt by the chiefs of staffs that have just signed the document, General Makarov and Mullen.

Soon all these documents will be published and you will be able to familiarize yourself with them.  On the whole, by characterizing our first day of work and the results of negotiations that we have had, I would like to say that I view them as a first but very important step in the process of improving full-scale cooperation between our two countries, which should go to the benefit of both states.  And if both states benefit by it, that means everybody will benefit by it.

I would like to emphasize in conclusion that our country would like to reach such a level of cooperation with the United States which would be realistically worthy of the 21st century, which will ensure international peace and security.  This is in our interest, and we are grateful to our American colleagues for the joint work we have done.

It is true that the solution of many world problems depends on the joint will of the United States and Russia.  Thank you.

PRESIDENT OBAMA:  Good afternoon, everybody, and I want to thank President Medvedev and the Russian people for their hospitality.  Michelle and I and our children are pleased to be here in Moscow, and to be here so early in my administration.

We’ve just concluded a very productive meeting.  As President Medvedev just indicated, the President and I agreed that the relationship between Russia and the United States has suffered from a sense of drift.  We resolved to reset U.S.-Russian relations, so that we can cooperate more effectively in areas of common interest.  Today, after less than six months of collaboration, we’ve done exactly that by taking concrete steps forward on a range of issues, while paving the way for more progress in the future.  And I think it’s particularly notable that we’ve addressed the top priorities — these are not second-tier issues, they are fundamental to the security and the prosperity of both countries.

First, we’ve taken important steps forward to increase nuclear security and to stop the spread of nuclear weapons.

This starts with the reduction of our own nuclear arsenals.  As the world’s two leading nuclear powers, the United States and Russia must lead by example, and that’s what we’re doing here today.  We have signed a Joint Understanding for a follow-on treaty to the START agreement that will reduce our nuclear warheads and delivery systems by up to a third from our current treaty limitations.  This legally binding treaty will be completed this year.

We’ve also agreed on a joint statement on nuclear security cooperation that will help us achieve the goal of securing all vulnerable nuclear materials within four years — progress that we can build upon later this week at the G8 summit.  Together, these are important steps forward in implementing the agenda that I laid out in Prague.

As we keep our commitments, so we must ensure that other nations keep theirs.  To that end, we had constructive discussions about North Korea and Iran.  North Korea has abandoned its own commitments and violated international law.  And that’s why I’m pleased that Russia joined us in passing a U.N. Security Council resolution that calls for strong steps to block North Korea’s nuclear and ballistic missile program.

Iran also poses a serious challenge through its failure to live up to international obligations.  This is not just a problem for the United States.  It raises the prospect of a nuclear arms race in the Middle East, which would endanger global security, while Iran’s ballistic missile program could also pose a threat to the broader region.  That’s why I’m pleased that we’ve agreed on a joint statement on cooperation on missile defense, and a joint threat assessment of the ballistic missile challenges of the 21st century, including those posed by Iran and North Korea.

Second, we have taken important steps forward to strengthen our security through greater cooperation.

President Medvedev and I agreed upon the need to combat the threat of violent extremism, particularly from al Qaeda.  And today, we’ve signed an agreement that will allow the transit of lethal military equipment through Russia to Afghanistan.  This is a substantial contribution by Russia to our international effort, and it will save the United States time and resources in giving our troops the support that they need.

Thanks to Admiral Mullen and his Russian counterpart, we’ve also agreed to resume military-to-military cooperation between the United States and Russia.  This provides a framework for improved cooperation and interoperability between our armed forces, so that we can better address the threats that we face — from terrorism to privacy.  We’ve also agreed to restore a Joint Commission on Prisoners of War and Missing in Action, which will allow our governments to cooperate in our unwavering commitment to our missing servicemen and women.

And third, we’ve taken important steps forward to broaden our cooperation on a full range of issues that affect the security and prosperity of our people.

President Medvedev and I are creating a U.S.-Russian Bilateral Presidential Commission to serve as a new foundation for this cooperation.  Too often, the United States and Russia only communicate on a narrow range of issues, or let old habits within our bureaucracy stand in the way of progress.  And that’s why this commission will include working groups on development and the economy; energy and the environment; nuclear energy and security; arms control and international security; defense, foreign policy and counterterrorism; preventing and handling emergencies; civil society; science and technology; space; health; education; and culture.  And this work will be coordinated by Secretary Clinton and Minister Lavrov, and Secretary Clinton will travel to Russia this fall to carry this effort forward.

Just to give you one example of this cooperation, is the new Memorandum of Understanding on health.  We’ve learned — most recently with the H1N1 virus — that a disease that emerges anywhere can pose a risk to people everywhere.  That’s why our Department of Health and Human Services will cooperate with its Russian counterparts to combat infectious, chronic, and non-communicable diseases, while promoting prevention and global health.

Finally, I’m pleased that Russia has taken the important step of lifting some restrictions on imports of U.S. livestock.  The cost of these restrictions to American business is over $1.3 billion, and we’ve now made important progress towards restoring that commerce.

I won’t pretend that the United States and Russia agree on every issue.  As President Medvedev indicated, we’ve had some frank discussions, and there are areas where we still disagree.  For instance, we had a frank discussion on Russia — on Georgia, and I reiterated my firm belief that Georgia’s sovereignty and territorial integrity must be respected.  Yet even as we work through our disagreements on Georgia’s borders, we do agree that no one has an interest in renewed military conflict.  And going forward, we must speak candidly to resolve these differences peacefully and constructively.

President Medvedev and I are committed to leaving behind the suspicion and the rivalry of the past so that we can advance the interests that we hold in common.  Today, we’ve made meaningful progress in demonstrating through deeds and words what a more constructive U.S.-Russian relationship can look like in the 21st century.  Tomorrow, I look forward to broadening this effort to include business, civil society, and a dialogue among the American and Russian people.

I believe that all of us have an interest in forging a future in which the United States and Russia partner effectively on behalf of our security and prosperity.  That’s the purpose of resetting our relations, that is the progress we made today, and I once again want to thank President Medvedev and his entire team for being such wonderful hosts and working so effectively with our teams.  Thank you.

MODERATOR:  Colleagues, now we begin the joint press conference of the President of the Russian Federation and the U.S. President.  You will be able to ask two questions.  Don’t forget to represent yourself.  And the first question goes to the U.S. media.

Q Thank you, and good evening to both Presidents.  President Obama, I’d like to ask you about the issue of trust, after this period of rocky relations between the countries, but also with the agreements that you’ve just laid out today.  Having spent time with President Medvedev, do you feel like you have full trust in him, and have you settled in your mind who is really in charge here in Russia — the President or Prime Minister Putin?

And President Medvedev, I’d like to ask you, polling shows that the American people have some hard feelings about — I’m sorry — that the Russian people have some hard feelings about America.  I’m wondering what you think President Obama can do to try to change this?

PRESIDENT OBAMA:  Well, first of all, this is now my second lengthy bilateral meeting with President Medvedev, and we’ve also had a series of telephone calls and other exchanges.  And throughout our interactions, I’ve found him to be straightforward, professional.  He is clear about the interests of the Russian people, but he’s also interested in finding out what the interests of the United States are.  And we have found I think an ability to work together extremely effectively.

So, yes, I trust President Medvedev to not only listen and to negotiate constructively, but also to follow up — follow through on the agreements that are contained here today.  And, again, I’m very appreciative not only of the manner in which he’s dealt with me, but also the manner in which our teams have worked together.  If you think about the short time frame from our meeting in London to today and the fact that we have essentially accomplished all the goals that we had set in London — and these are not insubstantial achievements — I think it’s a good sign for progress in the future.

Tomorrow I’ll be having breakfast with Prime Minister Putin.  I have not met him before.  I’m looking forward to that meeting.  My understanding is, is that President Medvedev is the President, Prime Minister Putin is the Prime Minister, and they allocate power in accordance with Russia’s form of government in the same way that we allocate power in the United States.

And so my interest is in dealing directly with my counterpart, the President, but also to reach out to Prime Minister Putin and all other influential sectors in Russian society so that I can get a full picture of the needs of the Russian people and the concerns of the Russian people.

And my strong impression is, is that President Medvedev and Prime Minister Putin are working very effectively together.  And our interest is dealing with the Russian government as a whole in order to achieve the improved bilateral relationship that I think can be accomplished.

PRESIDENT MEDVEDEV:  First of all, I would like to thank President Obama for the kind words he has just said about the spirit and the level of openness we enjoy in our personal relationship.  I said something about it already, previously.  Personal relationship are very important, especially when you speak about the building of interstate relationship.  And when the relationship between the governments and personal relationship are on the same level, positive — that’s always good for the relationship between countries.

Speaking of the attitude towards the American people, they are friendly.  I don’t see any negative elements there.  But when there are problems between the states, when there are negative signals being sent by the government, then of course these signals reflect on the mood of the ordinary people, and thus the better relationship between the countries are more — the more empathy people have towards each other in different countries.

We touched upon our different tasks between our meeting and the relationship between our countries, new ups and downs.  We, during the World War II, saved the world, and there was strategic partnership between us.  And now we also have a feeling that a lot depends on our relationship.  And the success in delivering on all those expectations, different ones, a lot depends on our efforts, bearing in mind that our people have always had sympathy towards — empathy towards each other.

MODERATOR:  (Inaudible), please, you have the floor.

Q (As translated.)  Thank you.  I have a question to both Presidents.  Russia and the U.S. are the largest nuclear powers in the world, accounting for 95 percent of warheads.  You have been working on the documents on the NPT for quite some time — in fact, since 1970s.  Do you think you will be able to have the situation in the NPT area under control when there are so many negative trends around the globe?

PRESIDENT MEDVEDEV:  Well, the non-proliferation problem is very important for our countries because we have and share the largest burden in the area of non-proliferation of strategic arms.  We do have the major nuclear arsenals and we have full responsibility for those arsenals.  And I agree with you totally — there are negative trends in the world and they are due to the emergence of new nuclear players.  Some of them are not officially members of the nuclear club, but they have aspirations to have nuclear weapons and declare so openly or, which is worse, doing it clandestinely.  And of course it has a very negative bearing on the world.

And due to reasons very well known, there are regions around the world where the presence of nuclear arms would create huge problems, and these are areas where we should concentrate our efforts together with our American partners.
Those regions, those areas, are well known.  There is no sense in naming them.  But it’s quite obvious that on the situation in the Middle East, on the Korean Peninsula, will depend the climate throughout the globe.  It’s our common, joint responsibility and we should make our utmost to prevent any negative trends there.  And we are ready to do that.  Our negotiations with President Obama have demonstrated that we share the same attitude towards this problem.

PRESIDENT OBAMA:  Well, I think President Medvedev said it well.  This is an urgent issue and one in which the United States and Russia have to take leadership.  It is very difficult for us to exert that leadership unless we are showing ourselves willing to deal with our own nuclear stockpiles in a more rational way.  And that’s why this post-START agreement is so important, and I’m hopeful that we can reduce our nuclear arsenals by as much as a third and hopefully can move even beyond that in subsequent agreements and treaties.

The critical issue that President Medvedev identified is the fact that we are seeing a pace of potential proliferation that we have not seen in quite some time, and he mentioned two specific areas.  In the Middle East, there is deep concern about Iran’s pursuit of nuclear weapons capability not simply because of one country wanting nuclear weapons, but the fact that if Iran obtained nuclear weapons, it is an almost — it is almost certain that other countries in the region would then decide to pursue their own programs.  And we would then see a nuclear arms race in perhaps the most volatile part of the world.

In the Korean Peninsula, we’ve already seen North Korea flout its own commitments and international obligations in pursuit of nuclear weapons.  And in all of these cases, as you see more proliferation of nuclear weapons, the possibilities not only of state actors targeting populations with nuclear weapons, but the possibility that those nuclear weapons could fall into the hands of non-state actors, extremist organizations, poses an extraordinary threat to both Russia and the United States.

So I’m pleased on the progress that we’ve made so far.  I think the fact that we got a joint threat assessment in terms of what ballistic missile capabilities and nuclear weapons could pose to our countries, that we will be conducting a review of that and making assessments to find ways that the United States and Russia can cooperate more effectively, that’s going to be very important.

I think continuing the pursuit of cooperation that already exists between Russia and the United States on loose nuclear materials and making sure those are secure, I think that’s going to be very important.  Structuring a new, reinvigorated non-proliferation treaty that applies a set of rules to all countries, allows them to pursue peaceful nuclear energy without having the capacity to weaponize that nuclear capacity, that is going to be very important.

And so we’ve actually suggested a global nuclear security summit that we intend to host next year, and I discussed with President Medvedev the strong possibility that in a subsequent summit it could be hosted by Russia, where we bring all the countries together around the world to start making progress on this critical issue.

MR. GIBBS:  Matt Spetalnick from Reuters.

Q Thank you.  Deep divisions over a proposed U.S. missile shield have contributed greatly to the deterioration of U.S.-Russian relations in recent years, and it does not seem that you gentlemen have finally resolved that issue either.  President Obama, you have said very clearly that you would not accept the linkage between the missile systems and arms control talks.  President Medvedev, you and Prime Minister Putin have said that these issues must be linked.  Are either of you gentlemen willing to budge or compromise on this issue?  And if not, could this also contribute to a blockage or obstacle to reaching a final START II agreement?

And also, President Obama, I wonder if you could give us your reaction to the Chinese government crackdown in the northwest of the country on rioting and unrest that has killed more than 140 people.

PRESIDENT OBAMA:  With respect to the China situation, unfortunately I’ve been travelling all night and in meetings all day, so I have not been fully briefed and I don’t want to comment until I actually see all the information.  But I assure you that our team will get a statement to you as soon as I’ve been able to do that.

On missile defense, we have agreed that we are going to continue to discuss this critical issue.  That is part of the joint statements that we’ve signed.  I also believe that it is entirely legitimate for our discussions to talk not only about offensive weapon systems but also defensive weapon systems.

Part of what got us through the Cold War was a sufficient sense of parity and deterrent capability; that both sides during those very difficult times understood that a first strike, the attempt to use nuclear weapons in a military conflict against the other, could result in a extremely heavy price.  And so any discussion of nuclear strategy, security, has to include defensive as well as offensive capabilities.

The difference that we’ve had has been on the specifics of a missile defense system that the United States views as a priority not to deal with Russia, but to deal with a missile coming in from Iran or North Korea or some other state, and that it’s important for the United States and its allies to have the capacity to prevent such a strike.  There is no scenario from our perspective in which this missile defense system would provide any protection against a mighty Russian arsenal.

And so, in that sense, we have not thought that it is appropriate to link discussions of a missile defense system designed to deal with an entirely different threat unrelated to the kinds of robust capabilities that Russia possesses.

Now, having said that, President Medvedev has been very clear that this is a point of deep concern and sensitivity to the Russian government.  I suspect when I speak with President — Prime Minister Putin tomorrow, he will say the same thing.  And what we would like to do is to work with Russia to advance a system that ensures that a stray missile, whether it was one or 10 or a handful of missiles coming from a third source, that we have the capabilities to prevent those from doing damage.  I think we can arrive at those kinds of understandings, but it’s going to take some hard work because it requires breaking down longstanding suspicions.

With respect to this particular configuration that was proposed several years ago, as you know, we’re undergoing a thorough review of whether it works or not, what has been proposed.  That review should be completed by the end of the summer and I indicated to President Medvedev that as soon as that review is complete, we will provide the Russian government our assessment of how we think we should proceed, and that will be the subject of extensive negotiations.

So, ultimately, I think the more progress we make on some of the issues that I discussed earlier — non-proliferation, being able to track ballistic missiles coming from other sources — to the extent that we are building deeper cooperation on those fronts, I think the more effectively we’re going to be able to resolve this issue.  I believe that over time we will end up seeing that the U.S.-Russian positions on these issues can be reconciled and that in fact we have a mutual interest in protecting both of our populations from the kinds of dangers that weapons proliferations is posing today.

PRESIDENT MEDVEDEV:  I’ll say a couple of words on this subject.  Of course anti-ballistic missile defense — not ballistic missile defense, but the problem of the third region area is a difficult subject for our discussion.

But I would like to draw your attention to what President Obama said, and I would like to point it out myself.  In our mutual understanding that has just been signed, we talk about the linkage between offensive and defensive weapons, and this already constitutes a step forward.  Some time ago, on this question, we had all — only differences.  Now this linkage is being stated and this opens up the opportunity of bringing positions closer to each other.

Secondly, nobody is saying that ballistic missile defense is harmful or is posing a danger.  It is aimed at resolving a number of practical tasks.  The question is of linking this configuration of missile defense with interests of other countries.  I would like to point out specially that our American partners, unlike what was happening in recent years, have taken a pause and now are studying this situation.  As a result of this, they will formulate their final position.

As at least, this is also a step forward in reaching possible compromise on this fairly difficult subject.  Before we just heard that all decisions have been made, they do not concern you, but they present no threat to you.  Our position is somewhat different.  You’re well familiar with it.  I’m not going to say it again.  Our understanding is that these decisions do concern us and we will have to come to terms on these positions.  We realize fully well that the number of threats, including link to the medium-range and ballistic missiles, is not diminishing but is growing in number.  So we all have to think about what configuration on the whole the global anti-ballistic missile defense could have.  And this, during our limited composition meeting, I mentioned to my colleague.

MODERATOR:  Distinguished colleagues, last question.  Channel Number One.

Q (As translated.)  Good evening.  The question is to both Presidents.  You spoke about your concerns about Afghanistan.  Can you be more specific?  What do Presidents think about the situation in that country?  There is a feeling that the counterterrorist operation in Afghanistan is having difficulties.  And to what extent cooperation between U.S. and Russia in transit can help to improve the situation, in greater detail, please?

PRESIDENT MEDVEDEV:  The subject of U.S.-Russian cooperation in Afghanistan is extremely important.  It is for this reason we paid so much attention to the discussion of this problem, and we have just signed an agreement that concerns transit.  It’s an important subject and we will of course continue cooperation with our American counterparts.

As concerns the current situation, it is — really is not simple.  I am not trying to say that it is being worsens, but in many aspects the progress is not available or is insignificant.  But we value the efforts that are being made by the United States together with the other countries in order to prevent the terrorist threat that was emanating and still coming from the Afghan soil.

We are prepared in this sense to a full-scale cooperation with our U.S. and other partners, including in transit areas.  We are prepared to help in the various aspects.  I don’t know to what extent — how quickly the situation will improve.  It depends to a large extent to the development of the political system in Afghanistan, to what extent the Afghan government will achieve successes in the economy — and it’s not a simple task.

Nevertheless we are prepared to continue with our efforts, the consultations with the Afghan side.  In Yekaterinburg I met the President of that country and I met the President of Pakistan, because both of these problems have to be resolved together.  And if we can join our efforts both in the economic peaceful field, and in terms of support of counterterrorist operation, the success will come sooner or later.

In the final analysis, the success, let me emphasis once again, will depend on the maturity of the Afghan state and the readiness of the Afghan society to change.

PRESIDENT OBAMA:  Well, as you may be aware, as soon as I came into office, we undertook a thorough review of our Afghan strategy to that point, in consultation with not only our NATO allies but all the forces internationally that have contributed to the efforts there.  And we concluded that we had not made as much progress as we should have, given the duration in which we’ve been in Afghanistan, and that we can improve it.

So our approach has been to say that we need to have a strong security system in place for the Afghan elections to be completed.  We have to train Afghan nationals for the army and police so that they can effectively secure their own country.  We have to combine that with more effective diplomatic efforts.  And we have to focus on development so that, for example, the people of Afghanistan don’t have to grow poppy, but have other crops and goods that they can make a living with.

Now, we have just begun the implementation of this new strategy, and so I think it’s too early to gauge its success so far.  I think by the time that we’ve completed the next election and the — either President Karzai or another candidate has taken his seat, then we will be able to I think do an additional review and see what other efforts we can take in order to improve the situation. I will tell you that Russia’s participation and contributions to this effort could be extraordinarily important.

Obviously Russia has its own concerns about extremism and terrorism.  Russia also has deep concerns about the drug trade and its infiltration into Russia.  And Russia has extraordinary capabilities when it comes to training police forces, training armies.  And so our hope is, is that as part of the broader presidential commission structure that we’ve put in place, that we’re going to further discuss both the military efforts in Afghanistan but also the development efforts and the diplomatic efforts so that we can make progress.

And President Medvedev is right that this is important for Afghanistan but it’s also important with respect to Pakistan.  And we’re going to have to think regionally in terms of how we approach these problems.  Obviously there are countries along the border of Afghanistan and Central Asia that are of deep strategic importance, and it’s very important that we also include them in these conversations about how we can move forward.

But I just want to thank again the Russian government for the agreement for military transit.  That will save U.S. troops both time and money.  And it’s I think a gesture that indicates the degree to which, in the future, Russian-U.S. cooperation can be extraordinarily important in solving a whole host of these very important international issues.

All right, thank you very much, everybody.

END
8:08 P.M. (Local)

00 Spanish Monarchs open cultural centre

ABC | abc.net.au

Spanish Monarchs open cultural centre

Posted Thu Jun 25, 2009 2:36pm AEST

The King and Queen of Spain have attended the opening of Australia’s first dedicated Spanish cultural centre in Sydney.

King Juan Carlos and Queen Sofia have toured the Cervantes Institute, which promotes Spanish language and culture around the world.

It is hoped that the visit will strengthen cultural and diplomatic ties between the two nations.

Today, the King and Queen have inspected the institute’s library and listened to a performance by the Sydney chamber choir singing Spanish Renaissance pieces.

The New South Wales Industrial Relations Minister, John Hatzistergos, also attended the opening of the centre together with other dignitaries from Spain.

00 El Rey inaugura en Sydney un nuevo Instituto Cervantes

El Rey inaugura en Sydney un nuevo Instituto Cervantes

El monarca señaló que el inglés y el español son las dos grandes lenguas internacionales del siglo XXI

25/06/2009 | Actualizada a las 08:08h | Cultura

Sydney. (dpa) – El rey de España, Juan Carlos I, y su esposa la reina Sofía, inauguraron hoy un nuevo Instituto Cervantes en Sydney, en el marco de su visita oficial de tres días a Australia. Los reyes realizaron una visita guiada por el centro tras la inauguración oficial.

El monarca señaló que hay más de 450 millones de personas que hablan español, y que el inglés y el español son las dos grandes lenguas internacionales del siglo XXI. “Este centro en Sydney constituirá una plataforma formidable para todos aquellos que estén interesados en nuestra lengua” y en la cultura española, destacó el monarca, quien a su vez expresó su confianza en el Instituto se convierta en un lugar de intelectuales, escritores y artistas.

Los reyes de España llegaron a Australia procedentes de Nueva Zelanda, para su primera visita oficial en más de dos décadas. Inauguraron una nueva embajada en Wellington, la capital de Nueva Zelanda.

00 Ideas Online, Yes, but Some Not So Presidential

Ideas Online, Yes, but Some Not So Presidential

By SAUL HANSELL
Published: June 22, 2009

WASHINGTON — On Jan. 21, his first full day in office, President Obama promised to open up the government, ordering officials to use modern technologies like Internet message boards and blogs to give all Americans a bigger voice in public policy.
Skip to next paragraph
Enlarge This Image

Hiroko Masuike for The New York Times
Beth Noveck, a New York Law School professor, is President Obama’s deputy chief technology officer for open government.

Well, the people have spoken. But many of them are not sticking to the topics at hand.

The White House made its first major entree into government by the people last month when it set up an online forum to ask ordinary people for their ideas on how to carry out the president’s open-government pledge. It got an earful — on legalizing marijuana, revealing U.F.O. secrets and verifying Mr. Obama’s birth certificate to prove he was really born in the United States and thus eligible to be president.

“Please, as fellow human beings of this great planet Earth, disclose all known information on space/UFO’s because the world needs to know,” wrote sprinter5160 on the site, whitehouse.gov/open, which attracted thousands of similar comments on fringe topics.

While it was not exactly what administration officials had in mind, they noted that democracy can be a bit messy.

“Even for people who want to talk about U.F.O.’s or the Kennedy assassination, we have created a forum for people to have a conversation with each other, and potentially to go off and organize and develop this further,” said Beth Simone Noveck, a New York Law School professor who is Mr. Obama’s deputy chief technology officer for open government.

Most of the suggestions were closely related to the topic at hand, like publishing a list of everyone who meets with the president, using computer graphics to track how rapidly agencies respond to Freedom of Information Act requests and installing webcams to monitor federal offices. The administration’s goal is to devise regulations that would tell federal agencies how to make their operations more open to the public.

Undeterred by some of the wilder suggestions, the White House proceeded Monday with the third phase of the process — asking people to collaborate online to draft language that could be used to create the final rules.

The experience so far shows just how hard it is to allow all voices to be heard and still have a coherent discussion. When millions of Internet users are invited to discuss every regulation, how can any real work get done? On the other hand, why bother opening up the government if views that are outside the mainstream — as defined by the usual collection of lobbyists and think tank scholars — are summarily dismissed?

The responsibility for sorting it all out falls to Ms. Noveck. She has permitted any proposal that was not abusive or repetitive onto the brainstorming site, just as the Obama transition team did not stop visitors to its Change.Gov site last fall from voting marijuana legalization as their top concern for the president-elect.

She argues that the experience of collaborative Web sites like Wikipedia proves that groups of users can police sites to keep small groups from spoiling things for everyone else. During the public brainstorming about rules for open government, the White House asked visitors to vote on the best ideas by clicking a thumbs-up or thumbs-down button, much as people vote on the most interesting news articles on sites like Digg.

The visitors advanced more than 3,900 ideas, which in turn spawned 11,000 comments that received 210,000 thumb votes.

The result? Three of the top 10 most popular ideas called for legalizing marijuana, and two featured conspiracy theories about Mr. Obama’s true place of birth. (Among the technical ideas that got a lot of support was a proposal to have the federal government press states and cities to follow open-government principles and a call for a central Internet site for all requests to the president and Congress, modeled after a site for petitions to the British prime minister.)

“This is Obama’s Madisonian moment,” said Clay Shirky, a professor at New York University and the author of “Here Comes Everybody,” a book about Internet collaboration. Just as James Madison, the nation’s fourth president, argued during the drafting of the Constitution that the government must protect the minority against the tyranny of the majority, Mr. Shirky said that government must also prevent small groups of loudmouths from hijacking the public debate.

“The first thing that happens when my mom and dad log into the system and they find it’s populated by U.F.O. people and birth-certificate people, they simply are not going to participate,” he said.

The White House tried to screen out some of the more unusual comments in the second phase of the process. Ms. Noveck summarized the most significant ideas, then invited comments on them at blog.ostp.gov. Visitors could flag off-topic comments, which were then shunted to a separate part of the site. That reduced the birth-certificate and U.F.O. comments to a relative trickle.

On Monday, the White House began Phase 3 of its project using yet another format: a wiki, an online tool that allows a group of people to collectively create and edit documents. Visitors will be able to submit and edit drafts of the open-government rules, similar to how people contribute to Wikipedia, the user-created online encyclopedia.

Ultimately, of course, “this is not policy by referendum,” said Ms. Noveck. The Office of Management and Budget will consider the public comments and the views of agency officials and White House staff and then put together its own formal draft of the open-government rules. After soliciting another round of public comment, the final rules will become effective and will govern the actions of federal agencies.

To some, the bumps in the process simply represent growing pains for a new and promising approach to government.

“The U.F.O. thing is healthy,” said Micah L. Sifry, the editor of TechPresident.com, a blog on politics and the Internet. “It’s weird there are some groups of people obsessed with it, but it’s a democracy, and you can’t make them go away.”

As people get used to this kind of participation, he said, “the mischief will be much less noticeable.”

Ms. Noveck has some confidence that the effort will result in better government because she has built something like this before. As a professor, she worked with the United States Patent Office to test a system that invited the public to help evaluate patent applications. Companies that apply for a lot of patents, like I.B.M. and General Electric, participated in the optional program because the public comments helped patent examiners consider their applications more quickly.

But then, I.B.M. never tried to patent a U.F.O.

00 Generación ‘ni-ni’: ni estudia ni trabaja

REPORTAJE: vida&artes

Generación ‘ni-ni’: ni estudia ni trabaja

Los jóvenes se enfrentan hoy al riesgo de un nivel de vida peor que el de sus padres – El 54% no tiene proyectos ni ilusión

Unos jóvenes en un banco
El virus del desánimo está minando la naturaleza vitalista y combativa de la gente joven.– JAVIER HERNÁNDEZ

Tan preparados y satisfechos con sus vidas, y tan vulnerables y perdidos, nuestros jóvenes se sienten presa fácil de la devastación laboral, pero no aciertan a vislumbrar una salida airosa, ni a combatir este estado de cosas. El dato asomaba hace poco, sin estrépito, entre los resultados de la última encuesta de Metroscopia: el 54% de los españoles situados entre los 18 y los 34 años dice no tener proyecto alguno por el que sentirse especialmente interesado o ilusionado. ¿Ha surgido una generación apática, desvitalizada, indolente, mecida en el confort familiar? Los sociólogos detectan la aparición de un modelo de actitud adolescente y juvenil: la de los ni-ni, caracterizada por el simultáneo rechazo a estudiar y a trabajar. “Ese comportamiento emergente es sintomático, ya que hasta ahora se sobrentendía que si no querías estudiar te ponías a trabajar. Me pregunto qué proyecto de futuro puede haber detrás de esta postura”, señala Elena Rodríguez, socióloga del Instituto de la Juventud (INJUVE).

La noticia en otros webs

Algunos sociólogos detectan una atmósfera juvenil muy inflamable Economizan sus esfuerzos por miedo a la frustración

La incertidumbre se impone en el empleo y en la pareja

Sólo el 40% de los universitarios tiene una actividad acorde con sus estudios

Están predispuestos a aprovechar el momento, “aquí y ahora”

“La gente no tiene prisa en hacerse mayor”, dice una voluntaria de ONG

La crisis ha venido a acentuar la incertidumbre en el seno de una generación que creció en un ámbito familiar de mejora continuada del nivel de vida y que ha sido confrontada al deterioro de las condiciones laborales: precariedad, infraempleo, mileurismo, no valoración de la formación. Las ventajas de ser joven en una sociedad más rica y tecnológica, más democrática y tolerante, contrastan con las dificultades crecientes para emanciparse y desarrollar un proyecto vital de futuro. Y es que nunca como hasta ahora, en siglos, se había hecho tan patente el riesgo de que la calidad de vida de los hijos de clase media sea inferior a la de los padres.

Ese temor ha empezado a extenderse, precisamente, entre la generación que de forma más abrumadora, siempre por encima del 80%, declara sentirse satisfecha con su vida. El virus del desánimo está minando la naturaleza vitalista y combativa de la gente joven aunque encontremos pruebas fehacientes individuales y colectivas de su consustancial espíritu de superación.

He aquí una muestra de resistencia a la adversidad extrema, junto a la prueba de cómo el discurso consumista ha resultado una trampa para tantos jóvenes audaces que creyeron en el maná crediticio y el crecimiento económico sin fin. “No podemos hacer frente a las hipotecas”, resume Luis Doña, de 26 años, padre de una niña de 15 meses, presidente de la Asociación de Defensa de los Hipotecados, que pretende renegociar la deuda contraída con los bancos y recabar la ayuda de la Administración. Llevados por el entusiasmo de haber encontrado un empleo estable, como comercial de una multinacional, él y su compañera adquirieron hace cuatro años un crédito hipotecario de 180.000 euros a pagar en 30 años para comprar un piso. “Teníamos que abonar 800 euros al mes, pero es que ya estábamos pagando 600 de alquiler. Hace un año, de buenas a primeras, nos quedamos los dos sin trabajo y ya se nos ha agotado el paro. Hemos conseguido que el banco nos cobre únicamente los intereses de la deuda, pero es que son 560 euros al mes y no los tenemos, porque no nos sale nada. ¿Desmoralizados? Lo que estamos es desesperados y eso que nuestro caso no es tan dramático como el de otras familias que han sido desahuciadas, han tenido que refugiarse en casa de su madre o su suegra”.

Eduardo Bericat, catedrático de Sociología de la Universidad de Sevilla, cree que la falta de ilusión hay que interpretarla, no tanto por los efectos de la crisis, como por el cambio cultural producido con anterioridad. “El modelo de vocación profesional que implicaba un proyecto vital de futuro y un destino final conocido, con sus esfuerzos y contraprestaciones, ha desaparecido. Ahora, la incertidumbre se impone en el trabajo y en la pareja y no está claro que la dedicación, el compromiso, el estudio o el título, vayan a tener su correspondiente compensación laboral y social”, afirma. Si la pregunta clásica de nuestros padres y abuelos: “¿Y tú, que vas a ser?” pierde fundamento, se entiende mejor que los esfuerzos juveniles respondan, más que a la ilusión por un proyecto propio, al riesgo de quedar descartado. “Si no estudio, si no hago ese master…”. Según el informe Eurydice, de la Unión Europea, sólo el 40% de los universitarios españoles tiene un trabajo acorde con sus estudios.

A los jóvenes no les resulta emocionalmente rentable comprometerse en un proyecto de vida definido porque piensan que estaría sometido a vaivenes continuos y que difícilmente llegaría a buen puerto. “Aplican la estrategia de flexibilizar los deseos y de restar compromisos; nada de esfuerzos exorbitantes cuando el beneficio no es seguro. Como el riesgo de frustración es grande, prefieren no descartar nada y definirse poco”, explica Eduardo Bericat. A eso, hay que sumar un acusado pragmatismo -nuestros chicos son poco idealistas-, y lo que los expertos llaman el “presentismo”, la reforzada predisposición a aprovechar el momento, “aquí y ahora”, en cualquier ámbito de la vida cotidiana. De acuerdo con los estudiosos, esa actitud responde tanto a la sensación subjetiva de falta de perspectivas, como al hecho de que el alargamiento de la etapa juvenil invita a no desperdiciar “los mejores años de la vida” y a combinar el disfrute hedonista con la inversión en formación.

A falta de datos sobre el alcance del “síndrome ni-ni”, el catedrático de Sociología de Sevilla explica que el pacto implícito entre el Estado, la familia y los jóvenes, pacto que compromete al primero a sufragar la educación y a la segunda a cargar con la manutención, alojamiento y ocio, hace creer a algunos jóvenes que en las actuales circunstancias pueden retrasar la toma de la responsabilidad. “Desarrollan una actitud nihilista porque no se les exige estar motivados, ni asumir responsabilidades y hay redes y paraguas sociales. En las convocatorias para cubrir plazas de becarios, me encuentro con aspirantes de treinta y tantos y hasta de cuarenta años, y lo curioso es que esos becarios se comportan como becarios. Es la profecía autocumplida. Si les llamas becarios y les pagas como tales terminarán convirtiéndose en becarios. Lo que me preocupa es la infantilización de la juventud”, subraya.

“Los jóvenes de ahora no son capaces de arriesgar, son conservadores”, constata Elena Rodríguez. ¿La tardía emancipación juvenil española (bastante por encima de los 30 años de media) es, sobre todo, fruto de la inestabilidad y precariedad del mercado laboral o consecuencia de ese supuesto conservadurismo? Aunque la diversidad y pluralidad de la juventud aconseja huir de las visiones unívocas, no se puede perder de vista que ellos no han tenido que vencer los obstáculos de las generaciones precedentes. “Miramos con descrédito la vida que nos ofrece la sociedad. Nuestros padres trabajaron mucho y se hipotecaron de por vida, pero tampoco les hemos visto muy felices. No es eso lo que queremos. La gente tiene pocas prisas para hacerse mayor”, explica Letizia Tierra, voluntaria de una ONG. Por lo general, las personas que trabajan en asociaciones de ayuda juvenil tienden a repartir sus juicios con la medida de la botella medio llena, medio vacía.

“En el CIMO (Centro de Iniciativas de la Juventud) vemos apatía y falta de ilusión generalizada. Muchos de los 200.000 nuevos titulados universitarios anuales afrontan con pesimismo la búsqueda de empleo. Saben que hay un elevado porcentaje de puestos de cajeros, reponedores, almacenistas, dependientes, etcétera ocupados por diplomados o licenciados”, afirma Yolanda Rivero, directora de esa asociación que atiende a diario a más de 600 jóvenes. Con todo, descubre también a muchos jóvenes capaces de adaptarse y de asumir retos y riesgos. “La generación JASP (jóvenes sobradamente preparados) tiene la ventaja de su mayor formación. A la vista del panorama, continúan formándose, viajan, trabajan, de camarero, si es preciso, para pagarse un master y aprovechan sus oportunidades, aunque, eso sí, en casa de papá y mamá hasta los 35 años, por lo menos”.

El catedrático de Psicología Social Federico Javaloy, autor del estudio-encuesta de 2007, Bienestar y felicidad de la juventud española, cree probado que nuestros jóvenes no son apáticos y desilusionados, aunque lo estén, por contagio ambiental. “Lo que pasa es que rechazan el menú laboral que les ofrecemos. El fallo es nuestro, de nuestra educación y nuestros medios de comunicación”, sostiene. Aunque las ONG encauzan en España las inquietudes que los partidos políticos son incapaces de acoger, tampoco puede decirse que la participación juvenil en ese campo sea extraordinaria. “Algo menos del 10% de los jóvenes participa en algún tipo de asociación, deportivas, en su mayoría, pero el porcentaje que lo hace en las ONG no llegará, seguramente, al 1%”, indica el catedrático de Sociología de la UNED, José Félix Tezanos. Autor del estudio Juventud y exclusión social, Tezanos detecta entre los jóvenes una atmósfera depresiva, un proceso de disociación individualista, condensado en la expresión “sólo soy parte de mí mismo” y el debilitamiento de la familia. “Se está produciendo una gran quiebra cultural. Los componentes identitarios de los jóvenes no son ya las ideas, el trabajo, la clase social, la religión o la familia, sino los gustos y aficiones y la pertenencia a la misma generación y al mismo género; es decir: elementos microespaciales, laxos y efímeros”, subraya.

El sociólogo de la UNED se pregunta hasta cuándo aguantará el colchón familiar español y qué pasará cuando se jubilen los padres que tienen a sus hijos viviendo en casa. A su juicio, el previsible declive de la clase media, la falta de trabajos cualificados -“el bedel de mi facultad es ingeniero”, indica-, el becarismo rampante, la baja natalidad y el desfase en gasto social respecto a Europa están creando una atmósfera inflamable que abre la posibilidad de estallidos similares a los de Grecia o Francia. “Podemos asistir al primer proceso masivo de descenso social desde los tiempos de la Revolución francesa”, augura.

Más apocalíptico se manifiesta Alain Touraine en el prólogo del libro de José Félix Tezanos. “Nuestra sociedad no tiene mucha confianza en el porvenir puesto que excluye a aquellos que representan el futuro” (…) “Se piensa que los jóvenes van a vivir peor que sus padres”, escribe el intelectual francés. Y añade: “Avanzamos hacia una sociedad de extranjeros a nuestra propia sociedad” (…) “Si hay una tendencia fuerte, es que tendremos un mundo de esclavos libres, por un lado, y a un mundo de tecnócratas, por otro” (…) “Los jóvenes tienen que trabajar de manera tan competitiva, que se acaban rompiendo (…) No están sólo desorientados, es que, en realidad, no hay pistas, no hay camino, no hay derecha, izquierda, adelante, detrás”.

Nadie parece saber, en efecto, con qué se sustituirá la vieja ecuación de la formación-trabajo-estatus estable, si, como pregonan estos sociólogos, la educación en la cultura del esfuerzo toca a su fin y gran parte de los empleos apenas darán para malvivir. Aunque estamos ante una generación pragmática que no ha soñado con cambiar el mundo, muchos estudiosos creen que la juventud no permitirá, sin lucha, la desaparición de la clase media. “El mundo que alumbró la Ilustración, la Revolución francesa y la Revolución industrial está agotado. La superproducción y la superabundancia material en estructuras de gran desigualad social carecen de sentido, hay que repensar muchas cosas, construir otra sociedad”, afirma Eduardo Bericat.

Las dinámicas encaminadas a establecer nuevas formas de relaciones personales, la búsqueda de una mayor solidaridad y espiritualidad, más allá de los partidos y religiones convencionales, los intentos de combatir la crisis y de conciliar trabajo y familia, el ecologismo y hasta el nihilismo denotan, a su juicio, que algo se mueve en las entretelas de esa generación. “Son alternativas que, aisladamente, pueden resultar peregrinas, pero que, en conjunto, marcan la búsqueda de un nuevo modelo de sociedad”, dice el profesor. ¿Será posible que esta juventud supuestamente acomodaticia y refractaria a la utopía sea la llamada a abrir nuevos caminos?

00 Social Networks Spread Iranian Defiance Online

Social Networks Spread Iranian Defiance Online
Newsha Tavakolian/Polaris, for The New York Times

Hundreds of thousands of Iranians marching in support for the presidential opposition candidate Mir Hussein Moussavi. More Photos >

[Article Tools Sponsored By]
By BRAD STONE and NOAM COHEN
Published: June 15, 2009

As the embattled government of President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad appears to be trying to limit Internet access and communications in Iran , new kinds of social media are challenging those traditional levers of state media control and allowing Iranians to find novel ways around the restrictions.
Skip to next paragraph

Follow the latest updates on The Times’ news blog, The Lede.

* Updates on Iran’s Disputed Election
* Iranian Readers: Share Your Views on the Outcome

Go to the Lede Blog »
Multimedia
[Opposition Defies Protest Ban in Tehran] Photographs
Opposition Defies Protest Ban in Tehran
Related
Defiance Grows as Iran’s Leader Sets Vote Review (June 16, 2009)
News Analysis: In Iran, an Iron Cleric, Now Blinking (June 16, 2009)
Times Topics: Iran | Social Networking

Iranians are blogging, posting to Facebook and, most visibly, coordinating their protests on Twitter , the messaging service. Their activity has increased, not decreased, since the presidential election on Friday and ensuing attempts by the government to restrict or censor their online communications.

On Twitter, reports and links to photos from a peaceful mass march through Tehran on Monday, along with accounts of street fighting and casualties around the country, have become the most popular topic on the service worldwide, according to Twitter’s published statistics.

A couple of Twitter feeds have become virtual media offices for the supporters of the leading opposition candidate, Mir Hussein Moussavi. One feed, mousavi1388 (1388 is the year in the Persian calendar), is filled with news of protests and exhortations to keep up the fight, in Persian and in English. It has more than 7,000 followers.

Mr. Moussavi’s fan group on Facebook has swelled to over 50,000 members, a significant increase since election day.

Labeling such seemingly spontaneous antigovernment demonstrations a “Twitter Revolution” has already become something of a cliché. That title had been given to the protests in Moldova in April.

But Twitter is aware of the power of its service. Acknowledging its role on the global stage, the San Francisco-based company said Monday that it was delaying a planned shutdown for maintenance for a day, citing “the role Twitter is currently playing as an important communication tool in Iran.”

Twitter users are posting messages, known as tweets, with the term #IranElection, which allows users to search for all tweets on the subject. On Monday evening, Twitter was registering about 30 new posts a minute with that tag.

One read, “We have no national press coverage in Iran, everyone should help spread Moussavi’s message. One Person = One Broadcaster. #IranElection.”

The Twitter feed StopAhmadi calls itself the “Dedicated Twitter account for Moussavi supporters” and has more than 6,000 followers. It links to a page on the photo-hosting site Flickr that includes dozens of pictures from the rally on Monday in Tehran.

The feed Persiankiwi , which has more than 15,000 followers, sends users to a page in Persian that is hosted by Google and, in its only English text, says, “Due to widespread filters in Iran, please view this site to receive the latest news, letters and communications from Mir Hussein Moussavi.”

Some Twitter users were also going on the offensive. On Monday morning, an antigovernment activist using the Twitter account “DDOSIran” asked supporters to visit a Web site to participate in an online attack to try to crash government Web sites by overwhelming them with traffic.

By Monday afternoon, many of those sites were not accessible, though it was not clear if the attack was responsible — and the Twitter account behind the attack had been removed. A Twitter spokeswoman said the company had no connection to the deletion of the account.

The crackdown on communications began on election day, when text-messaging services were shut down in what opposition supporters said was an attempt to block one of their most important organizing tools. Over the weekend, cellphone transmissions and access to Facebook and some other Web sites were also blocked.

Iranians continued to report on Monday that they could not send text messages.

But it appears they are finding ways around Big Brother.

Many Twitter users have been sharing ways to evade government snooping, such as programming their Web browsers to contact a proxy — or an Internet server that relays their connection through another country.

Austin Heap, a 25-year-old information technology consultant in San Francisco, is running his own private proxies to help Iranians, and is advertising them on Twitter. He said on Monday that his servers were providing the Internet connections for about 750 Iranians at any one moment.

“I think that cyber activism can be a way to empower people living under less than democratic governments around the world,” he said.

Global Internet Freedom Consortium, an Internet proxy service with ties to the banned Chinese spiritual movement Falun Gong, offers downloadable software to help evade censorship. It said its traffic from Iran had tripled in the last week.

Shiyu Zhou, founder of the organization, has no idea how links to the software spread within Iran. “In China we have sent mass e-mails, but nothing like in Iran,” he said. “The Iranian people actually found out by themselves and have passed this on by word of mouth.”

Jonathan Zittrain, a professor at Harvard Law School who is an expert on the Internet, said that Twitter was particularly resilient to censorship because it had so many ways for its posts to originate — from a phone, a Web browser or specialized applications — and so many outlets for those posts to appear.

As each new home for this material becomes a new target for censorship, he said, a repressive system faces a game of whack-a-mole in blocking Internet address after Internet address carrying the subversive material.

“It is easy for Twitter feeds to be echoed everywhere else in the world,” Mr. Zittrain said. “The qualities that make Twitter seem inane and half-baked are what make it so powerful.”

00 China’s College Entry Test Is an Obsession

China’s College Entry Test Is an Obsession

Adam Dean for The New York Times

Nervous family members and well-wishers waited Sunday outside in Tianjin, China, as students took the test that will determine whether they will go to college.

Published: June 12, 2009

TIANJIN, China — For the past year, Liu Qichao has focused on one thing, and only one thing: the gao kao, or the high test.

Skip to next paragraph

Related

Times Topics: China

Adam Dean for The New York Times

A student on his way to the exam hall. The test lasts nine hours.

The New York Times

Some prepare for the test at a strict Tianjin boarding school.

Fourteen to 16 hours a day, he studied for the college entrance examination, which this year will determine the fate of more than 10 million Chinese students. He took one day off every three weeks.

He was still carrying his textbook from room to room last Sunday morning before leaving for the exam site, still reviewing materials during the lunch break, still hard at work Sunday night, preparing for Part 2 of the exam that Monday.

“I want to study until the last minute,” he said. “I really hope to be successful.”

China may be changing at head-twirling speed, but the ritual of the gao kao (pronounced gow kow) remains as immutable as chopsticks. One Chinese saying compares the exam to a stampede of “a thousand soldiers and 10 horses across a single log bridge.”

The Chinese test is in some ways like the American SAT, except that it lasts more than twice as long. The nine-hour test is offered just once a year and is the sole determinant for admission to virtually all Chinese colleges and universities. About three in five students make the cut.

Families pull out all the stops to optimize their children’s scores. In Sichuan Province in southwestern China, students studied in a hospital, hooked up to oxygen containers, in hopes of improving their concentration.

Some girls take contraceptives so they will not get their periods during the exam. Some well-off parents dangle the promise of fabulous rewards for offspring whose scores get them into a top-ranked university: parties, 100,000 renminbi in cash, or about $14,600, or better.

“My father even promised me, if I get into a college like Nankai University in Tianjin, ‘I’ll give you a prize, an Audi,’ ” said Chen Qiong, a 17-year-old girl taking the exam in Beijing.

Outside the exam sites, parents keep vigil for hours, as anxious as husbands waiting for their wives to give birth. A tardy arrival is disastrous. One student who arrived four minutes late in 2007 was turned away, even though she and her mother knelt before the exam proctor, begging for leniency.

Cheating is increasingly sophisticated. One group of parents last year outfitted their children with tiny earpieces, persuaded a teacher to fax them the questions and then transmitted the answers by cellphone. Another father equipped a student with a miniscanner and had nine teachers on standby to provide the answers. In all, 2,645 cheaters were caught last year.

Critics complain that the gao kao illustrates the flaws in an education system that stresses memorization over independent thinking and creativity. Educators also say that rural students are at a disadvantage and that the quality of higher education has been sacrificed for quantity.

But the national obsession with the test also indicates progress. Despite a slight drop in registration this year — the first decline in seven years — five million more students signed up for the test than did so in 2002.

China now has more than 1,900 institutions of higher learning, nearly double the number in 2000. Close to 19 million students are enrolled, a sixfold jump in one decade.

Liu Qichao, 19, a big-boned student with careful habits, plans to be the first in his family to go to college. “There just were not a lot of universities then,” said his father, Liu Jie, who graduated from high school in 1980 and sells textile machinery. His son harbors hopes of getting into one of China’s top universities.

But the whole family was shaken by the results of his first try at the gao kao last June.

The night before the exam, he lingered at his parents’ bedside, unable to sleep for hours. “I was so nervous during the exam my mind went blank,” he said. He scored 432 points out of a possible 750, too low to be admitted even to a second-tier institution.

Silence reigned in the house for days afterward. “My mother was very angry,” he said. “She said, ‘All these years of raising you and washing your clothes and cooking for you, and you earn such a bad score.’

“I cried for half a month.”

Then the family arrived at a new plan: He would enroll in a military-style boarding school in Tianjin, devoting himself exclusively to test preparation, and retake the test this June.

Despite the annual school fee of 38,500 renminbi (about $5,640) — well above the average annual income for a Chinese family — he had plenty of company.

One of his classmates, Li Yiran, a cheerful 18-year-old, estimated that more than one-fourth of the seniors at their secondary school, Yangcun No. 1 Middle School, were “restudy” students.

Ms. Li said she learned the hard way about the school’s strict regimen. When her cellphone rang in class one day, the teacher smashed it against the radiator. Classes continue for three weeks straight, barely interrupted by a one-day break.

Days after most of their classmates left for home, Mr. Liu and Ms. Li were still holed up last week in their classrooms. Mr. Liu’s wrist was bruised from pressing the edge of his blue metal desk, piled with a foot-high stack of textbooks.

Ms. Li’s breakfast was a favorite among test-takers: a bread stick next to two eggs, symbolizing a 100 percent score.

Hours after they finished the test on Monday, both students had collected the answers from the district education bureau and begun the laborious process, with the help of their teachers, of estimating their scores.

Mr. Liu calculated that his score leaped by more than 100 points over last year’s dismal performance. But he was still downcast, uncertain whether he would make the cutoff to apply to top-tier universities. The cutoff mark can vary by an applicant’s place of residence and ethnicity.

Ms. Li, on the other hand, was exhilarated by her estimate of 482.5, figuring it was probably high enough for admittance to a college of the second rank.

By Wednesday evening, both were buoyed by news of the cutoff scores for their district. His estimated mark was well above the one needed to apply to first-tier schools, and hers was a solid five points above the notch for the second tier.

Before the test, Ms. Li’s aunt warned her that this was her last chance for a college degree. Even if she knelt before her mother and begged, her aunt said, her mother would refuse to let her take the test again.

But Ms. Li, a hardened veteran of not one but two gao kao ordeals, had a ready retort: “Come on. Even if my mother kneels down before me, I will refuse to take this test again.”

Huang Yuanxi contributed research.