Victorianism as a Fusion of Neoclassical and Romantic Ideas and Attitudes
George P. Landow, Professor of English and the History of Art, Brown University
“>M. H. Abrams enormously influential The Mirror and the Lamp: Romantic Theory and the Critical Tradition (1953) provides a valuable way into the problem of defining Victorianism in art and literature. Abrams begins his argument by pointing out that the once near-universal tendency to discuss art in terms of author and artist arrived on the scene quite late in the 2,500 year-old history of aesthetics and critical theory:
To pose and answer aesthetic questions in terms of the relation of art to the artist, rather than to external nature, or to the audience, or to the internal requirements of the work itself, was the characteristic tendency of modern criticism up to a few decades ago, and it continued to be the propensity of a great many — perhaps the majority — of critics today. This point of view is very young when measured against the twenty-five-hundred-year history of Western theory of art, for its emergence as a comprehensive approach to atm shared by a large number of critics, dates back not much more than a century and a half. [3]
Before he can demonstrate the “momentous consequences for the identification, the analysis, the evaluation, and the writing of poetry” (3) of these comparatively recent ways of looking at literature and art, Abrams explains that all discussions of them discuss four elements — text or work, author, reality or nature, and audience — but define themselves by which one of the four they emphasize.
Four elements in the total situation of a work of art are discriminated and made salient, by one or another synonym, in almost all theories which aim to be comprehensive. First, there is the work, the artistic product itself. And since this is a human product, an artifact, the second common element is the artificer, the artist. Third, the work is taken to have a subject which, directly or indirectly, is derived from existing things — to be about, or signify, or reflect something which either is, or bears some relation to, an objective state of affairs. This third element, whether held to consist of people and actions, ideas and feelings, material things and events, or super-sensible essences, has frequently been denoted by that-word-of-all-work, “nature;” but let us use the more neutral and comprehensive term, universe, instead. For the final element we have the audience: the listeners, spectators, or readers to whom the work is addressed, or to whom, at any rate, it becomes available. [6]
Having thus set forth the framework of the argument to follow, Abrams proceeds, beginning with the relation of the work (or text) to nature (or universe), to explain the implications of each approach. Abrams labels mimetic those explanations of “the work of art as essentially an imitation of aspects of the universe” (8), and he discusses the quite different forms it takes in the writings of Plato and Aristotle. A central part of all such mimetic theories — and one which probably surprises most modern readers — lies in their conception of the roles of artist and poet, who do not have what Abrams terms “a determinative function;” that is, although poets are “indispensable,” their “personal faculties, feelings, or desires are not called upon to explain the subject matter or form of a poem” (11). No one cares, in other words, if the poet is sincere or original: only accuracy, only truthfulness count.
The next category, the approach to art that emphasizes its relation to audience, Abrams labels pragmatic, “since it looks at the work of art chiefly as a means to an end, an instrument for getting something done, and tends to judge its value according to its success in achieving that aim. . . . The central tendency of the pragmatic critic is to conceive a poem as something made in order to effect certain responses in its readers” (15). This essentially rhetorical approach, which characterizes critical theory from the Renaissance through much of the eighteenth century, leads in turn to an emphasis upon distinct genres, or artistic and literary kinds, each with its own specific techniques and ends. Tragedy, for example, must have noble characters, elevated diction, and employ certain poetic devices, such as elaborate metaphor, to produce pity and fear. Pastoral, lyric, satire, burlesque all have their own rules, for this kind of critical position sees literary genres or kinds as forms of technology that can or should produce specific definable effects in the reader. Once again, no one cares if the poet is sincere or original: only effect and effectiveness, and skill in following the rules, counts.
With romantic or expressive theories come all the criteria with which we are familiar at last: spontaneity, sincerity, originality, intensity . . . alienation. “Poetry is the overflow, utterance, or projection of the thought and feelings of the poet; or else (in the chief variant formulation) poetry is defined in terms of the imaginative process which modified and synthesizes the images, thought, and feelings of the poet. . . . A work of art is essentially the internal made external” (21-22) or expressed. I always think of this approach as reactive: the artist-poet confronts nature or society, has a reaction that takes the form of a powerful emotional and imaginative experience that he or she later expresses. Kinds, literary or painterly genres, even the audience no longer appears central, and in fact the subjective nature of the artist-poet’s experience almost guarantees several things. First, the resulting text or picture will appear to the audience as new, novel, and possibly strange or even weird. Second, the creator will always be ahead of the audience. Third, as Wordsworth put it, truly great art and literature advance so beyond the audience’s expectations that it must create the taste by which it is to be enjoyed. And fourth, manifestos and prefaces, critics and interpretative criticism, become centrally important, as does the notion of an avante garde, since someone has to explain and defend art and artist to audience.
Leaving aside the fourth category — objective theories ranging from Art for Art’s Sake to New Criticism that concentrate upon the work itself, we can turn to the question of Victorianism in literature and the arts. For all the great poetry and art produced by the romantic generations, many nineteenth-century readers and writers believed their approach tended towards egotism and excessive subjectivity. Nonetheless, at the same time that Thomas Carlyle proclaimed that his contemporaries should close their Byron and open their Goethe (which many of his readers reconfigured as “close Byron and read Carlyle”), they had passed a great divide — one of the central ones in Western intellectual and social history — and could not return to the elegant wit and scathing satire of the Augustans. As E. D. H. Johnson pointed out more than half a century ago in The Alien Vision of Victorian Poetry (1952), the Victorian project involved finding literary and artistic means of bridging a series of what they understood to be binary oppositions: self and society, personal and political, subjective and objective. Above all, as Carlyle managed to do in Sartor Resartus, Tennyson in In Memoriam, and Dickens in Great Expectations, they had to find public uses for very private experiences without either becoming egotistical or makes themselves vulnerable. Thus, the necessity of developing the dramatic monologue and new forms of both autobiography and autobiographical fictions. In other words, the Victorians had to find a way to create a synthesis of what Abrams calls pragmatic and expressive forms of art. Characteristically Victorian literature therefore attempts bravely, and often successfully, to combine the individuality, originality, intensity, and above all sincerity of Wordsworth and Keats with publicly accessibility and social relevance of Pope and Johnson.
References
Abrams, M. H. The Mirror and the Lamp: Romantic Theory and the Critical Tradition. NY: Oxford UP, 1953.
03 Movements and Currents in Nineteenth-Century British Thought
Movements and Currents in Nineteenth-Century British Thought
George P. Landow, Professor of English and Art History, Brown University

Since the 1830s the Victorians and those who have followed them have identified several opposed trends, tendencies, movements, or loosely organized schools of Victorian thought. Here are some of them:
1. Progressive vs. Conservative
At the very beginning of Victoria’s reign, John Stuart Mill argued that contemporary British thought divided into progressive and conservative schools derived from Jeremy Bentham and Samuel Taylor Coleridge. Following Mill’s lead, modern critics have identified followers of each strain or party.
Progressives, Liberals, or Rationalists: James Mill (Mill’s father), Mill himself John Bright
Conservatives, Tories, or Reactionaries: Carlyle, Disraeli, Pugin, Newman, Arnold, Ruskin, Morris
2. Radical Progressive vs. Tory Radical vs. Conservative
Another take on political schools recognizes that the terms , liberal, radical, and conservative mean different things in the twentieth century than they did in the last.
Progressives, Liberals, or Rationalists: James Mill (Mill’s father), J. S. Mill, Thomson, Bradlaugh, John Bright. Characteristic beliefs: middle-class fear of government intervention, emphasis upon freedom of action. In today’s political context, this once extreme left-wing movement from the early nineteenth century would be considered reactionary or a party of extreme right.
Tory Radicals, Christian Socialists, Marxists: Carlyle, Arnold, Ruskin, Morris. Characteristic beliefs: need for strong central government, welfare or interventionist state; anti-aristocractic; ambivalent attitude toward middle class.
Conservatives, Tories, or Reactionaries: Carlyle, Disraeli, Pugin, Newman, Keble, Pusey, Hopkins Characteristic beliefs: pro aristocracy, medieval revival, social hierarchy, established (or official) state religion.
3. Hebrew vs. Hellene (or Moral vs. Aesthetic)
Using Matthew Arnold’s opposition of an emotional, fundamentalist (or Puritanical) Evangelical Protestantism to an elite Hellenic school, a series of scholar-critics, of whom Graham Hough and David DeLaura are the most important, have proposed the following kind of opposition:
Hebrews: Ruskin, Carlyle, Dickens, Eliot, Mrs. Gaskell, the Brownings. Characteristic forms: prophetic modes, social protest, autobiographies emphasizing conversion, dense, often grotesque image and analogy, contemporary, often middle-class subjects.
Hellenes: Newman, Arnold, D. G. Rossetti, Swinburne, Pater, Wilde. Characteristic forms: would-be elitist subjects, emphasis on clarity, greater use of classical myth, secular version of Tractarian notions of reserve.
4. Believers vs. Nonbelievers
span class=”book”>Orthodox Believers: Newman, Keble, Ruskin (early), C. Rossetti, E. B. Browning, MacDonald, Hopkins
Idiosyncratic, unorthodox believers — usually liberal Christians: Dickens, MacDonald, Ruskin (after 1870), Tennyson, R. Browning (?)
Nonbelievers: Bentham, Mill, Carlyle, Darwin, Huxley, Clough, Arnold, Ruskin (late 1850s through 1860s), D. G. Rossetti, Morris, Swinburne, Hardy, Eliot, Thomson
Suggested Readings
Buckley, J. H. The Victorian Temper: A Study in Literary Culture. Cambridge: Harvard UP, 1964.
DeLaura, David J. Hebrew and Hellene in Victorian England: Newman, Arnold, and Pater. Austin: U of Texas P, 1969.
Houghton, Walter E. The Victorian Frame of Mind, 1830-1870. New Haven: Yale UP, [c. 1956].
Johnson, E. D. H. The Alien Vision of Victorian Poetry. Princeon: Princeton UP, 1952.
Mill, John Stuart. “Bentham” and “Coleridge,” Autobiography and Other Writings. Ed. Jack Stillinger. Boston: Houghton Mifflin, 1969. Originally appeared in 1838-1840 The London and Westminster Review.
|
|
- http://www.victorianweb.org/philosophy/thought1.html
05 Difficulties of Victorian Poetry
|
Dick Sullivan raises a really important point when he asks, “What might have happened to English-language poetry if [Hopkins had] been published in his lifetime and had to compete with Tennyson, Swinburne, and Browning?” [“Hopkins and the Spiritual“] Looking at the reception of the early, radically experimental poetry of Tennyson and Browning, the answer seems fairly obvious: almost certainly nothing would have happened unless Hopkins had resolutely kept publishing and been lucky enough to find a few critics who would defend his work in print. Like these other poets, Hopkins would have been greeted with complete non-comprehension when he was noticed or reviewed at all, and if and when he was reviewed, he would probably have received the same kind of mockery they did. Now that the three poets to whom Sullivan compares Hopkins have become canonical — which means in practice “read in secondary schools and universities” — we forget how the Victorians at first found them amazingly difficult to read.
Why Did their first readers find Browning, Tennyson, and Swinburne so difficult?
Let’s begin with Browning because in some ways his difficulties for the reader have so much in common with Hopkins’s. Readers long found Browning’s poetry incomprehensible for the following reasons:
- He created a radically new form for which his audience did not know the rules.
- He used difficult, often arcane words.
- He made difficult, often obscure allusions.
- He did not, in other words, write with a conventional sense of audience.
Taking the second and third points, I should point out that both Swinburne and Tennyson present the same difficulties, Tennyson, for example, anticipating e.e. cummings by a century and coining new words, using nouns as verbs, and so on. Browning, unlike the other two poets, was home-schooled and self taught, and he enjoyed reading obscure biographies and reference works with the result that he had an unsure sense of what he could expect his readers to know. (He didn’t always realize when he was being difficult!) The scholarly and equally well-read Swinburne similarly often showed little attention to the needs of his audience, characteristically attempting to popularize his political and poetic hero Victor Hugo with a poem filled with dozens of allusions to the French author’s works that only a someone who had practically memorized them could possible recognize. What we see here with all four poets, in other words, is the Modernist elitist attitude toward the audience that assumes it’s the reader’s job to work hard to understand the text or work of art. Or as one of the great twentieth-century novelists (Joyce? Faulkner?) put it, “You can’t read my novels. You can only re-read them.” Don’t expect to get it on the first read!
As difficult as might be these poets’ choice of words and allusions, their novel poetic forms created the most serious problems for readers. Let’s look at Browning, who used a radically new poetic form — essentially a new genre with its own rules — and readers simply did not know what to do. Along with Tennyson and Rossetti, Browning invented the dramatic monologue, particularly that form of it in which the speaker does not represent the poet and, therefore, his statements were certainly not those that the poet himself believed. Accustomed to taking it for granted that the first-person speaker was either the poet or his idealized persona, audiences did not know what to do when they encountered the homicidal maniac of “Porphyria’s Lover” and the even more terrifying Duke in “My Last Duchess.” It’s as hard to over-estimate the importance of this point as it is even to realize it after so many years of teaching Browning in secondary schools as an exercise in close reading: Early and mid-Victorian readers simply had no clue what to do first when encountering a speaker in a poem who did not serve as an obvious stand-in for the author and whose statements therefore had to be received with scepticism or at least reservation of judgment. If this statement doesn’t seem obvious, go back to those two famous Browning dramatic monologues and take note of the point at which you first realized you could not trust the speakers. Browning, as contemporary anecdotes demonstrate, was simply unreadable for most in his intended audience: all biographies of Browning tell the story of a well-known person who was given a copy of Browning’s admittedly difficult Paracelsus while recovering from an illness; horrified by the fact that he could not understand the poem at all, the invalid thought that the illness had destroyed his mind and was considering suicide until others assured him they couldn’t understand it either.
What happened so that secondary school students can now read — and understand — Browning (or at least the shorter dramatic monologues)? Are we so much more intelligent than the Victorians? Hardly. Wordsworth explains it all when he stated in the 1815 edition of Lyrical Ballads that great poets have to “create the taste by which they are to be enjoyed.” In other words, readers have to learn the new rules — the signals to the readers — that let them know what to do next. The idea of combining two different forms or modes in the dramatic monologue (drama and lyric) was just as unsettlingly unexpected as Wordsworth and Coleridge’s similarly joining two supposedly opposed ones in lyrical ballads, since the lyric was a non-narrative form while the ballad was essentially narrative. But readers learn. Remember, although early twentieth-century readers found stream-of-consciousness narration of James Joyce and Virginia Wolfe initially incomprehensible, after three or four decades undergraduates learned the rules, and now pop genres, such as detective stories and science fiction novels, use the technique.
Tennyson’s experimental poetic forms
Tennyson and Swinburne also write with new forms. In addition to his early use of the then-novel dramatic monologue, Tennyson wrote radically experimental challenges to narrative in his two great long poems, In Memoriam and Idylls of the King. Anticipating (and certainly heavily influencing T. S. Eliot), he builds a poetry of fragments in In Memoriam that challenges all previous elegies, calling into question their too-easy linear movement from grief to consolation. (His use of poetic segments containing moments of illumination and climax incidentally provides the model for Hopkins’s “Wreck of the Deutchland.”) In Memoriam makes such a radical challenge to both conventional poetic form and narrative that more than any other work intended for print — more even than Cortazar’s Hopkscotch, Sterne’s Tristram Shandy, or Coover’s “The Babysitter” — this poem anticipates computer-based hypermedia. When I teach and write about the ways one can both satisfy readers with the individual blocks of texts (or lexias) in hypertext and yet make them want to continue (i.e. follow links), I point students to In Memoriam, which also shows how chains of imagery, such as the poems’s use of “hand,” “dream,” and “type,” can provide a new kind of unity in a networked text (See Hypertext, pp. 37-38, 141-43). Tennyson continues his experimental poetic project in The Idylls of the King (1859-1888), in which his characteristic use of flashbacks, parabolic commentary, and complex plotting anticipates the modernist narrative of Faulkner.
And then there is Swinburne, probably the Victorian poet as far from Hopkins in just about every way one can imagine: whereas Hopkins published almost nothing, Swinburne, the leading expert of his time on Jacobean drama, published many critical books, including one of the first on Blake, as well as many volumes of poetry and poetic drama; whereas Hopkins was a politically conservative, devout christian who led a celibate, abstemious life, Swinburne, the radical democrat and atheist, first became known as the bard of perversion before he became the bard of the great leftist cause of the Victorian period — the liberation and unification of Italy. Perhaps the one poetic quality that most separates the two authors appears starkly in the length of their poems. Many of Hopkins’s finest works take the form of the sonnet and its variants — extremely dense poems with layers of imagery; with the exception of Swinburne’s Dirae (curses), bitterly satirical sonnets on political themes, all of his major poems are very long, and, unlike those of both Hopkins and Tennyson, they do not build towards moments of vision but employ a circular structure that returns again and again to a provisional imaginative center, adding layer after layer of image and meaning. Nonetheless, one must not overemphasize the differences between the poets, for a comparison reveals surprising similarities. In their early careers both wrote fine dramatic monologues — Swinburne’s “Hymn to Proserpine” and Hopkins’s “A Soliloquy of one of the Spies left in the Wilderness.” Both frequently employ sophisticated biblical allusions — both in fact draw upon the types of Christ and Satan in Genesis 3:15 — though Swinburne usually does so satirically and Hopkins as a center to his devotional poetry. Perhaps surprisingly, both men use masochism and masochistic imagery as a means of expressing their sense of being in the world. Both men went through periods of intense depression and personal crisis that significantly marked their poetry.
Finally, both men create a poetry of meditation that provides multiple ways into a main point of belief, and to do so both employ dense layering of allusion as a means of overcoming the shortcomings of language. Of course, devout belief and fervent atheism divide them pretty sharply, allowing us to see certain parings of their poems as binary opposites, at least on this one point. Thus, just as Rossetti’s House of Life is (as Dick Fredeman pointed out long ago) an anti-In Memoriam, so Swinburne’s brilliant landscape meditation, “Evening on the Broads” (text), is very much an anti-“Windhover.” But “Evening on the Broads” nonetheless reveals points of convergence with Hopkins. This dense poem, which presents the brief moment the sun hovers on the horizon before plunging into night as an image of human life, struggles to find language adequate to a transient existence, as does Hopkins’s “Spring and Fall;” Hopkins, like the Tractarian poets, such as Keble and early Newman, believes earthly phenomena to be divinely intended symbols of Christ, heaven, and spiritual truths. Swinburne, in contrast, finds that such phenomena symbolize nothing, except perhaps death, time, and change.
Hopkins and Poetic Difficulty
In some ways Hopkins’s best poetry has turned out to be easier to read and therefore more widely read than Swinburne’s finest works, and this fact derives significantly from their length: the brevity of Hopkins’s poems made them perfectly suited to the word-by-word and line-by-line close reading of the New Criticism (whose adherents created Hopkins’s fame and position in the canon). The poetry of Hopkins, far more than that of Swinburne, has that most crucial of qualities: it is teachable and therefore frequently taught. In contrast, because Swinburne really doesn’t fit any pedagogical method, he creates hard work for teachers. Both Hopkins and Swinburne write a poetry of meditation, but the very brevity of Hopkins’s best poems makes ruminating on individual words and lines seem more attractive than trying to unravel Swinburne’s individual lines, in which he builds metaphors upon metaphors, emphasizing both the shortcomings of human language and the fact that poetry really exists only in the language; for him it’s all we have.
References
Landow, George P. Hypertext: The Convergence of Contemporary Critical Theory and Technology. Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press, 1992. Pp. 37-38, 141-43.
or
Landow, George P. Hypertext 3.0: New Media and Critical Theory in an Era of Globalization. Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press, 2006. Pp. 74-75, 219, 225.
|
|
- http://www.victorianweb.org/authors/hopkins/difficulty.html
|
|